379: Product strategy is changing. Are you ready? – with Ron Adner, PhD

What product managers need to know about having an ecosystem strategy

Today we are talking about strategy. It’s an important topic because our work as product managers and innovators should be in alignment with our organization’s strategy, but strategy may not be what you think it is.

To help us better understand strategy and the large changes taking place in many businesses, Dr. Ron Adner joins us. He is a Professor of Strategy and Entrepreneurship at the Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth College. Previously he was the Akzo-Nobel Fellow of Strategic Management at INSEAD. His research examines value creation and competition when industry boundaries are changing. His latest book is Winning the Right Game: How to Disrupt, Defend, and Deliver in a Changing World. He has received high praise from his contemporaries, including Clayton Christensen who described his work as “Path-breaking,” and Jim Collins (author of Good to Great) who called him “one of our most important strategic thinkers for the 21st century.”

Summary of some concepts discussed for product managers

[2:59] Make this simple—what is strategy?

Strategy is an indication of what you want to do. A classic test for strategy is, “Do you know what you need to do and what you need to not do?” Strategy is how you allocate your resources and choose which opportunities to forgo while pursuing the ones you’ve chosen.

Mainstream strategy includes Porter’s five forces, low cost differentiation, and Clay Christensen’s work on being more sensitive to substitute threats. These tools are based on the problems we had in the 1950’s-1990’s, but the world has changed. It’s getting harder to stretch those frameworks that were built for a world well-defined by industry into the world we face today. Examples of classic disruption like Southwest Airlines relied on new technology, but the industry was the same. Today, the industry is no longer the industry. For example, what is Fintech—insurance, investment, gambling, personal identity? The boundaries around industries are shifting, and that’s why we need a new approach to strategy.

[7:35] What are some examples of changes in the business environment that influence strategy development?

Take the automotive industry. We used to think of it as Ford vs. GM, and then Toyota started delivering higher quality cars at a lower price, but they were all selling cars. Tesla is different. They’re making electric vehicles, but they’re also making an electric charging infrastructure and servicing vehicles with over-the-air updates. They’re the dealer, fuel provider, and service station.

Now the buzzword isn’t industry; it’s ecosystem. The clean boundaries of knowing who is doing what have broken down. A hundred and twenty years ago, autos were an ecosystem. People were trying to figure out who would make cars, pave the roads, and provide fuel. As those relationships became stable and accepted, we conceptualized the auto world as industries. Now we’re moving back into an ecosystem mode—rewiring and reconfiguring. The challenge for strategy today is we’re transitioning from the stable configuration of industry into a new reconfiguration of ecosystem. All the old tools in our toolbox were built for a world of industries and break down in this world of ecosystems.

[10:55] How has the perspective of business model innovation impacted the ecosystem perspective?

An ecosystem is the structure through which partners interact to deliver their value proposition. It’s anchored in value proposition, and you have a multiplicity of partners that need to be aligned relative to one another in a certain structure. An ecosystem strategy looks at that configuration and how you get partners into that alignment.

The business model is a company-centric view of how to make money.