The Great Sources with Rabbi Shnayor Burton

S6, E12 Shemona Perakim; Should a Person be Moderately Humble or Extremely Lowly?

02.08.2024 - By Rabbi Shnayor BurtonPlay

Download our free app to listen on your phone

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

This shiur was generously sponsored by an anonymous donor for the merit of the speedy, safe and healthy return of the Hostages.

The source sheet for this shiur is available here.

Highlights

0:30 The 2 divergent Torahs and 2 divergent purposes of mitzvahs: one for the masses, the other for the elite individuals

9:30 Maimonides explicitly contradicts himself regarding whether a person should be moderately humble or practice extreme self-abasement

22:00 Maimoinides' own personal change of character as a result of experience and years

27:00 How life changes a person, and why a different kind of behavior is appropriate for young people than for older people

30:30 Maimonides teaches both a theoretical ideal and what is appropriate in practice

33:00 We no longer treat people according to how they themselves treat us

38:00 An eye for an eye (https://youtu.be/fpAdWSy_mZA?si=yoCYdDm12MGHZrRw)

42:00 Some texts are meant only as ideals and not to be executed in practice

44:00 We must study the ways of Hashem, and we must also know that we can't ever perfectly emulate them

47:30 Extreme lowliness stands in tension with good character and wisdom

This series is a project of the Jacob Lights Foundation.

More episodes from The Great Sources with Rabbi Shnayor Burton