Small Town Murder

By James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman

Society & Culture Comedy

What's Small Town Murder about?

Two comedians look at a small town, what makes it tick, and a murder that took place there. In depth research, horrible tragedy, and the hosts' comedic spin on the whole thing. New episodes every Thursday!!

4.9

54,178 ratings

Download our free app to listen on your phone

LAST EPISODE

#423 - The Killer Has Somet...

09.21.2023

This week, in Walsenburg, Colorado, the whole area panics, when a man is found in front of his house, very bloody, and barely conscious. But his real concern is his wife, who turns out to be dead, in the kitchen. ...

Small Town Murder episodes:

09.21.2023 #423 - The Killer Has Something In His Pants - Walsenburg, Colorado This week, in Walsenburg, Colorado, the whole area panics, when a man is found in front of his house, very bloody, and barely conscious. But his real concern is his wife, who turns out to be dead, in the kitchen. ...
09.17.2023 #425 - COMING SOON! Your Stupid Opinions Join comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman with their new podcast as they explore the most opinionated part of the internet: The Reviews Section! Get ready for the premiere of Your Stupid Opinions... September 18, 2023. Subscribe and we will ...
09.15.2023 #422 - Dead In A Ditch - Claymont, Delaware This week, in Claymont, Delaware, when a missing man is found, beaten to death, in a ditch, there are some clues, but the case quickly goes cold. Until a tip to detectives unravels a complex plan, involving baseball bats, an ...
09.14.2023 #421 - Three Murders & Six Congenital Idiots - Starke, Florida This week, in Starke, Florida, a woman tries to help her sister find someone to scare the sister's husband into an easier custody battle. This leads to an ex-Marine, turned mercenary, who advertises his services in a magazine. Of course, ...
09.08.2023 #420 - Cheating, Lies & Corn Rakes - Earlville, Iowa This week, in Earlville, Iowa, problems enter the marriage of a farm couple, leading to cheating, and many hurt feelings. Tensions simmer, under the surface, and this all ends with someone having a large corn rake stuck in their back, ...
09.07.2023 #419 - A Major Lack Of Aloha - Hilo, Hawaii This week, in Hilo, Hawaii, a young woman, who has dreamed of Hawaii her entire life, moves to the big island, with tragic results. A simple Christmas Eve bike ride, along a scenic ocean road, ends in finding one shoe, ...
09.01.2023 #418 - The Stranger & The Psychic - Scarborough, Maine This week, in Scarborough, Maine, a missing young woman sends the area into a panic, but things get even worse, when she's found. The investigation reveals some strange facts, but it comes down to being between three different suspects, her ...
08.31.2023 #417 - No Body, No Crime... Except For That Head - Hazelton, Idaho This week, in Hazelton, Idaho, after a marital break up everything seems fine, with both parties, moving on, an progressing in their lives. But one person is absolutely holding a grudge, and a small thing sets them off. Next thing ...
08.25.2023 #416 - The Incredible Disappearing Head - North Canton, Ohio This week, in North Canton, Ohio, the paths of two very different people cross in a strange little trailer park. One of these people is an ex-Marine, turned hairdresser, with a long history of violence, and generally crazy behavior. The ...
08.24.2023 #415 - Dirty Desires, Killer Consequences - Columbia, Illinois This week, in Columbia, Illinois, the perfect couple have the perfect family. In the perfect house. In the perfect town. They even have perfect jobs. But things get very imperfect when a sudden affair changes all future plans, and eventually ...
08.18.2023 #414 - Don't Anger The Princess - Bryant, Arkansas This week, in Bryant, Arkansas, a perfect little family isn't so perfect, when their teenage daughter begins to disobey, do drugs, and not listen to her parents. This causes major problems, and drama within the family, causing divorce, and untold ...
08.17.2023 #413 - Judging The Devil By His Horns - Pittsfield, Massachussets This week, in Pittsfield, Massachusetts, A very terrible man, somehow finds people just as terrible as him, including a man who has his teeth sharpened, tongue split, and has horns implanted into his forehead, to commit some of the most ...
08.11.2023 #412 - The Bloody Basement Breakfast Club - Bismarck, North Dakota This week, in Bismarck, North Dakota, one local basement is the all purpose hangout for a pair of teen sisters, their boyfriends, and several other local losers & runaways. They live there, drink, shoot meth, and plan crimes. After one ...
08.10.2023 #411 - Her Emo Eyes Have Powers - Terra Linda, California This week, in Terra Linda, California, a young lady has a very strange home life, with a seemingly mentally ill mother, who the young woman calls "Hitler". She delves into a world where she calls herself a High Priestess, and ...
08.04.2023 #410 - The Longest Night - Green River, Wyoming This week, in Green River, Wyoming, a wild night comes from a love triangle gone crazy! When two men seem to be in love with the same woman, they argue, then decide to be friends. This causes an insane scene ...
08.03.2023 #409 - Cousins, Lovers & Killers - Summerfield, North Carolina This week, in Summerfield, North Carolina, a very unlikely couple, decide to take on their families, and everyone else they feel has wronged them, with horrifying, murderous results. Why are they an unlikely couple? Because they're first cousins, from a ...
07.28.2023 #408 - Never Saw That Coming - Townshend, Vermont This week, in Townshend, Vermont, what appears to be a nice story, of a couple, living a nice life, turns very dark when it's least expected. This leaves one member of this couple brutally beaten to death, in the driveway, ...
07.27.2023 #407 - Attempted Threesomes, Russian Brides & Time Travel - Alsea, Oregon This week, in Alsea, Oregon, a man who seems to charm everyone he comes in contact with, finds love in Russia, and quickly moves to bring her to the US for marriage. What she doesn't know, is that he's already ...
07.21.2023 #406 - Not Even A Little Sorry - Flagstaff, Arizona This week, in Flagstaff, Arizona, a move across the country doesn't quite cure the relationship between a young couple, instead causing an attempted break up. This results in terribly brutal murder, complete with a horrifying final deed. Surprisingly, the not ...
07.20.2023 #405 - The Horny Teacher's Lounge - Upper Merion Township, Pennsylvania This week, in Upper Merion Township, Pennsylvania, a twisted tree of relationships, among a group of suburban high school teachers spins completely out of control, when a meek, married woman is romanced by a fellow teacher, who is seemingly irresistible ...
07.14.2023 #404 - The Laughing Psychopath - Marrero, Louisiana This week, in Marrero, Louisiana, a night of bar hopping & fun leads to a drunken group of people, driving in a car. It all turns very dark, when violence comes out of nowhere, resulting in one of the party ...
07.13.2023 #403 - Three Suspects & A Moron - Silver City, New Mexico This week, in Silver City, New Mexico, a young woman is found, brutally killed, floating in her own bathtub. The suspects include her police officer/soon to be ex-husband, her too good to be true new boyfriend, and the weirdo who ...
07.07.2023 #402 - Fornication, Forensics & French Fries - Morris, Alabama This week, in Morris, Alabama, a woman finds love, after the tragic death of her first husband, but then finds even more love, with her church's Pastor. This leads to problems in their marriages, and some messy conversations. But when ...
07.06.2023 #401 - A Seriously Crazy Cuisine - Morrice, Michigan This week, in Morrice, Michigan, a successful man, with a good job, and nice family seemingly loses his mind. He begins having strange fantasies, and losing touch with reality. From there, the story goes in a completely different direction, when ...
06.30.2023 #400 - The Bad Seed - Eureka, Utah This week, in Eureka, Utah, a man who started getting arrested at age 10, was in prison by 15, and participating in a very well known riot/murder while behind bars. Once he gets out, he's predictably primed for violence, and ...
06.29.2023 #399 - Titanic Insanity - Port Angeles, Washington This week, in Port Angeles, Washington, when it looks like the story is going one way, it takes a complete left turn into unexpected, and shocking cold bloodedness. When a woman is found, dead, in an overturned car, it becomes ...
06.23.2023 #398 - I Just Needed To See Blood - Liberty, New York This week, in Liberty, New York, a sitcom like living arrangement turns out to not be such a hilarious situation, when a mother, her grown daughter have a middle of the night confrontation that seemingly starts over loud music, dancing, ...
06.22.2023 #397 - Stunning Brutality, Shocking Stupidity - Dumfries, Virginia This week, in Dumfries, Virginia, the disappearance of a young boy, from his neighborhood produces an underwhelming police response, and the loss of vital evidence that allows an obvious monster to continue to roam the streets. This results in him, ...
06.16.2023 #396 - Sifting Through Suspects - Rock Hill, South Carolina This week, in Rock Hill, South Carolina, what appears to be a person, taking their own life, turns out to be anything but that. It's actually a cold blooded, terrifying murder that occurred when someone slipped into a home, in ...
06.15.2023 #395 - Not Answering The Call Of Duty - Foster, Rhode Island This week, in Foster, Rhode Island, a beef between some teens, and a local police officer kicks off a wild story that leads to multiple murders, prison, lawsuits, calls of small town corruption, and a huge outcry from horrified townspeople. ...
06.09.2023 #394 - The Sudden Passion Of Boobs - Nassau Bay, Texas This week, in Nassau Bay, Texas, did a lesbian affair between two housewives set off a series of events that culminated in a completely different woman, killing her husband, in a public place, in front of many witnesses, and even ...
06.08.2023 #393 - The Neighborhood Monster - Arkansas City, Kansas This week, in Arkansas City, Kansas, a very smart, and popular college girl disappears, and family, friends & police look at one young man for answers, and find even more than they bargained for. They find a person who has ...
06.02.2023 #392 - The Face Of Evil - Nowra, New South Wales, Australia This week, in Nowra, New South Wales, Australia, a couple with a very happy, and seemingly perfect life, unknowingly has a plan set in motion against them. This plan is formed by a jealous friend, who wants to live their ...
06.01.2023 #391 - The Family Death Curse - Vaughan, Mississippi This week, in Vaughan, Mississippi, a well known, and liked family, who appear to have a multi generational death curse, just disappears. This prompts hundreds of law enforcement officers to search for miles around, and has locals on the edge ...
05.26.2023 #390 - Too Fat To Kill - Ramsey, New Jersey This week, in Ramsey, New Jersey, a woman hears her boyfriend being murdered, over the phone, but by the time police get to him, it's too late. The focus lands on a family member of an ex, but that man ...
05.25.2023 #389 - The Legend Of Curly's Cheese - Mount Horeb, Wisconsin This week, in Mount Horeb, Wisconsin, a terribly bloody, and awful murder scene is found in a home's finished basement. A very inefficient murder weapon is found, under the body, and detectives believe everyone was home when it happened. We ...
05.19.2023 #388 - A Wild Night At The Trailer Park - Cameron, Missouri This week, in Cameron, Missouri, an angry man, upset by his wife leaving him, and moving into a trailer with another man, decides he needs a plan. At first, his plan is to win back the heart of his true ...
05.18.2023 #387 - The Rantings Of A Serial Killer - Clarksburg, West Virginia This week, in Clarksburg, West Virginia, police receive several letters, and a 2 hour audio tape, from what appears to be a serial killer. He claims at least 6 murders, and several fires, and police start to put together that ...
05.12.2023 #386 - Cheers To My Killer - Whitewood, South Dakota This week, in Whitewood, South Dakota, a crumbling relationship is certainly not helped by a five year affair, but everything looks like it will work out just fine. Until, one night, when one of the pair is left with a ...
05.11.2023 #385 - Lust, Blood, Cruelty & Snakes - Lothian, Maryland This week, in Lothian, Maryland, what appears to a horrifically bloody, but pretty standard murder/suicide, until some very strange evidence comes to light, followed by some kinky evidence... Then, text messages that blow the lid off the entire plot. A ...
05.05.2023 #384 - Dismembering Grandma - Trail Creek, Indiana This week, in Trail Creek, Indiana, an unhappy woman uses her teenage sons as her her personal murder squad, forcing them to kill both their father, and grandmother. They almost get away with it, too, considering they almost did a ...
05.04.2023 #383 - The Brutality Of Strawberry Shortcake - West Wendover, Nevada This week, in West Wendover, Nevada, a smart, popular high school student vanishes into thin air, and a huge team of volunteers begin to look for her. When she's found, the scene is so terrible, that even the most seasoned ...
04.28.2023 #382 - Who Tasted The Blood? - Salem, New Hampshire This week, in Salem, New Hampshire, three drifting young men decide to murder some young women, after extensive viewings of the movie "Scream", and a healthy binging of meth & booze. Their plan turns out to be tragically successful, after ...
04.27.2023 #381 - Hunting The Home Hermit - Caledon, Ontario, Canada This week, in Caledon, Ontario, Canada, an odd man, who is described as a loner, with a foul odor, closes his antique shop, to spend his time living in an attic, when he's not living in the woods. He also ...
04.21.2023 #380 - The Atomic Wedgie Killer - McLoud, Oklahoma This week, in McLoud, Oklahoma, easily the strangest murder that we've ever covered occurs, when a biker & his step son decide to get together, to drink copious amounts of booze, and hang out, even though they're currently in the ...
04.20.2023 #379 - The Satanic Corporate Ladder - Brandenburg, Kentucky This week, in Brandenburg, Kentucky, a very strange tale unfolds, when a young woman takes a walk down the street, and disappears. When she is found, murdered horribly, attention immediately focuses on her boyfriend, and his best friend, who claim ...
04.14.2023 #378 - The Open Marriage Blues - Niantic, Connecticut This week, in Niantic, Connecticut, a swinging couple leads a very normal life, to the outside world, but definitely gets freaky on the weekends. While the husband is away on a fishing trip, the wife is horribly murdered, leaving a ...
04.13.2023 #377 - A Deadly Love Hexagon - Hope, Alaska This week, in Hope, Alaska, seemingly every man in the state is after one young lady. A transplant, from New Orleans, by way of an attempted New York modeling career, who is currently the star dancer at the biggest strip ...
04.07.2023 #376 - A Perverted Mind - Vinings, Georgia This week, in Vinings, Georgia, screams are heard through a small apartment building, leading to several emergency calls being made, including one where the dispatcher can only hear faint moaning. Detectives arrive to find a terribly murdered woman, and a ...
04.06.2023 #375 - Bones In The Bonfire - Andover, Minnesota This week, in Andover, Minnesota, a seemingly small family squabble, snowballs into what can definitely be described as a powder keg of anger. A plan is made, and it's a brutal one, involving a crossbow, sledgehammer, heavy hammers, a baseball ...

Older episodes