Murder, She Told

The Case of Paula Roberts: David Willoughby

03.01.2022 - By Kristen SeaveyPlay

Download our free app to listen on your phone

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

1983. Augusta, Maine.

Part 1 - In December of 1983, all of central Maine was pitching in efforts to help search for a young woman who was abducted during a robbery at a local ice cream shop—21-year-old UMF student, Paula Roberts.

A month later, when the city editor of the Kennebec Journal showed up to work, the call of a lifetime was waiting for him: a man who had a first hand account of what happened to Paula... and who had killed her. The catch? He wanted to remain anonymous. But the KJ told him that in order to print the story, he needed to show them where Paula's body was located.

The following day, the anonymous tipster was arrested: 26-year-old David Willoughby. But David insisted he was innocent. It was his step-brother, Phillip, who killed her. Not him. But there's a lot of circumstantial evidence against him... will the jury find him innocent?

This is part one of the story of Paula Roberts, and one of the most sensational murder trials in Maine's history.

Detailed sources can be found on murdershetold.com.

Connect on Instagram @murdershetoldpodcast

Support the show here

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More episodes from Murder, She Told