The Parallax Podcast

Beneath the Pillow: A Murder, Myth, and the Dark Side of the Tooth Fairy


Listen Later

This Halloween, The Parallax Podcast takes a sinister detour into the folklore of childhood’s most innocent visitor—the Tooth Fairy. But beneath the glittering coins and tiny treasures lies a much darker history, one stained with blood and bone collecting.

Karisa unearths the Tooth Fairy’s origins, tracing her path from European bogeymen who collected children’s teeth for dark magic to the Nordic nomads who wore necklaces made from children's teeth.

Then, Willow recounts a real-life horror: the murder of Helle Crafts, whose body was never found—only a single crown of her tooth, left behind like a grotesque offering in the winter snow.

With eerie tales, historical nightmares, and a dash of Halloween dread, this episode will make you think twice before slipping a tooth under your pillow. After all… what takes them, might not give back.

Keywords:
Tooth Fairy, dark folklore, Halloween special, unsolved murder, child myths, Lamia, bogeyman, true crime, macabre history, female hosts, Karisa and Willow, creepy rituals, paranormal, horror stories, cursed legends.

Sleep tight. Don’t let the Fairy bite. 🦷✨🔪

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Parallax PodcastBy Karisa DeLay and Willow Grace