Erin and Julia discuss how this episode seems like it's in a different timeline of the show. Though it has it's entertaining moments, The Scare was a low point in season one.

That said, one of Erin's favorite Pacey scenes happens in this episode, Joey almost gets taken by a serial killer, and the woman Julia dubs the poor man's Stevie Nicks "buys" teenagers wine and crashes their seance...

Join us for Season 1, Episode 11, of the classic 90s teen drama, Dawson's Creek!

Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy

Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.

Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who makes our voices sound warm and inviting, and gives us the scoop about growing up in New England.

Find Erin on Instagram at @erin.hensley

Find Julia on Twitter and Instagram @Pesty1079

Rare Bird Books is @rarebirdlit and at rarebirdbooks.com