When "Easy A" was picked as this week's movie, Donny and Chelsea knew right away who they wanted to cover it with. Enter Nava and Sophie, co-hosts of "Podcrushed," the podcast where Penn Badgley reads your middle school story. What Sophie and Nava didn't realize, though, is that if they are the "scholarly" nostalgia podcast, "I Am The Cute One" is the equivalent of walking into a monkey's cage at the zoo. 

Donny demands they tell their Gleek status within the first five minutes of the show before accidentally talking sh*t on their co-host (sorry, Penn!) Then, Chelsea admits to being bullied by dog instagram accounts and then gives Donny a backhanded compliment in the form of a Pokemon evolution theory. And then, when Sophie and Nava think they've caught on to the chaos and tell a story about tickle parties, Donny one-ups them with his secret weapon: lick attack time.

For bonus episodes and unedited & unhinged audio and video recaps, subscribe to our Patreon!

Shop our merch!

Follow Us on Social Media!

TikTok: @cuteonepodcast

Chelsea: @ohnochels

Donny: @realdonnywood

Support the show

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices