Originally Aired: September 6, 1959

In Gunsmoke #387, "Matts Decision," Marshal Matt Dillon faces mounting frustration from nearly everyone in Dodge City. The episode begins with Chester complaining about rowdy prisoners who've made a mess of the jail, and matters only get worse from there. Doc Adams storms into the Marshal's office angry about a drunk who stole and wrecked his buggy, demanding Matt do something about the lawless drovers. Hotel owner Mr. Dobey wants Matt to act as doorman and keep loafers out of his chairs, while Miss Bagley represents a group of town ladies concerned about bottles in the streets and general disorder when the Texas herds arrive.

Matt finds himself caught between impossible expectations and the reality of frontier law enforcement. As complaints pile up and tempers flare, even Chester manages to destroy the Marshal's hat while cleaning up after prisoners. The mounting pressure from all sides forces Matt to examine his role as lawkeeper and consider what he can realistically accomplish in a rowdy cattle town where drovers and townspeople constantly clash.