Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast

By Not Your Mom Media

Society & Culture

What's Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast about?

Moms and Mysteries is a true crime podcast hosted by Mandy and Melissa, two friends who deep dive into a new case each week. Conversational in tone and heavy on the levity, you’ll enjoy their original takes on both the well-known, and those lesser heard of true crime stories.

4.6

5,972 ratings

Download our free app to listen on your phone

LAST EPISODE

Ernesto Miranda: The Story ...

09.26.2023

This week we are discussing Ernesto Miranda, the namesake behind “Miranda Rights”, and the landmark case that reshaped the American legal procedure to this day. Thank you to our sponsors! If you want to try Beam’s best-selling Dream Powder, get ...

Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast episodes:

09.26.2023 Ernesto Miranda: The Story Behind Miranda Rights This week we are discussing Ernesto Miranda, the namesake behind “Miranda Rights”, and the landmark case that reshaped the American legal procedure to this day. Thank you to our sponsors! If you want to try Beam’s best-selling Dream Powder, get ...
09.19.2023 The Murder of Suzanne Jovin This week we are discussing the murder of a student at Yale University, Suzanne Jovin, and the investigation into finding her killer. Thank you to our sponsors! Are you looking for your next podcast? Then you need True Crime Feed ...
09.14.2023 Listen Now - Exposed: Cover-Up at Columbia University Feed Drop Description: Dr. Robert Hadden was a trusted OB-GYN at Columbia University. Friendly, caring, unassuming… and behind the closed door of exam rooms, one of the most prolific sexual predators in New York City. During his 25-year career, he ...
09.12.2023 The Lane Bryant Murders This week we are discussing the heartbreaking murders of five people inside a Lane Bryant store in Tinley Park and where the investigation is today, more than a decade later. Ways to get involved with Season of Justice: Go to ...
08.29.2023 The Murder of Robert Fingerhut This week we are discussing Robert Fingerhut, whose murder was planned by his partner, Donna Roberts, and her boyfriend, Nathaniel Jackson, while Nathaniel served time behind bars. Thank you to Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research for your help with ...
08.22.2023 The Murder of Alexandra Pesic This week we are discussing a young mother named Alexandra Pesic who faced harassment and stalking from her ex-mother-in-law, Jelka Pesic. The situation escalated as Jelka orchestrated a murder plot against her former daughter-in-law, Alex. Thank you to Anna Luria ...
08.15.2023 The Disappearance of Peggy McGuire This week we will be discussing the tumultuous relationship between Peggy McGuire and her husband Thomas McIntosh. Despite attempts to leave the relationship, including seeking a protective order, she tragically disappeared in November 2015 with her family still searching for ...
08.08.2023 The Murder of Mike Emert This week we are discussing the murder realtor Mike Emert and the subsequent investigation that revealed a connection between the perpetrator and multiple other murders. Thank you to Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research for your help in researching this ...
08.01.2023 Missing in Chautauqua County This week we are discussing the cases of Lori Bova and Corrie Anderson, who both went missing in Chautauqua County, New York. Please check-out Detective Perspective to hear more about Yolanda Bindics story. Thank you to Haley Gray with Haley ...
07.25.2023 The Disappearance of Christi Nichols On the night of December 10, 1987, Christi Jo Nichols went missing after she and her husband Mark Nichols hired a babysitter for their children. Mark claims Christi went to sleep after returning home, but she was never seen again. ...
07.18.2023 The Murder of Dave Laut This week we’re discussing the murder of Dave Laut, a renowned Olympian whose life was tragically cut short by his wife, Jane Laut. Although the police quickly identified Jane as the perpetrator, a lingering question emerged: Was this an act ...
07.17.2023 Introducing: Suspect Season 3: Five Shots in the Dark Leon Benson spent 24 years in an Indiana state prison for the 1998 murder of a young man named Kasey Schoen. His conviction hinged on the testimony of two eyewitnesses – but what if their memories turned out to be ...
07.11.2023 The Wrongful Convictions of Arthur Almendarez, John Galvan, and Francisco Nanez This week we are discussing the wrongful convictions of Arthur Almendarez, John Galvan, and Francisco Nanez after a fire took place in an apartment complex in Chicago. Thank you to Ana Luria and Haley Gray for research assistance! Thank you ...
07.04.2023 The Murder of Allen Ross This week, we are discussing the tragic demise of filmmaker Allen Ross, who met an untimely death after becoming involved with the Samaritan Foundation, a religious cult situated in Guthrie, Oklahoma. Stick around for a special guest on Last Thing ...
06.27.2023 Ted Kaczynski: The True Story of the Unabomber This week, we’re discussing the compelling story of Ted Kaczynski, the Unabomber. We’ll begin by exploring his seemingly unremarkable upbringing, and shed light on the chilling accounts of his involvement in inhumane experiments during his college years. Finally, we’ll discuss ...
06.20.2023 The Murder of Tiffany Booth This week we are discussing the murder of Tiffany Booth and the ongoing manhunt for the person police say is responsible, Eduardo Clemente. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. Thank you to our sponsors! Want to EARN money ...
06.13.2023 The Murder of Marlene Warren This week we are discussing Marlene Warren, a beloved mother whose murder went unsolved for 33 years, even after multiple witnesses saw someone dressed as a clown shoot her in broad daylight. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. ...
06.06.2023 The Murder of Jared Bridegan- Update Episode This week we are discussing the murder of Jared Bridegan, a beloved father of 4 in Jacksonville Beach, Florida, as well as the updates that have occurred in his case since we first covered it last year. Research by Haley ...
05.30.2023 The Murder of Michael Tardio and Christopher Monson- REPLAY Next week we are back with a brand-new episode. Thank you so much for being patient with us in the midst of illnesses. In the meantime, check-out this episode you may have missed from last year! This week we are ...
05.23.2023 The Murder of Dr. Thomas Kolman *Sorry for the delayed upload* This week we are discussing Dr. Thomas Kolman, a physical therapist who authorities claim was murdered by his best friend and dentist, Dr. Gilberto Nunez. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. A HUGE ...
05.16.2023 The Murder of Jamie Faith This week we are discussing the murder of Jamie Faith and the thorough investigation that ended with two arrests. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. Thank you to this week’s sponsors! Want to earn cash back on the ...
05.09.2023 The Champion Family Murders This week we are discussing the Champion family and the attack that left three out of four members tragically murdered. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. Thank you to our sponsors! Tired of searching for the perfect doctor ...
05.02.2023 The Murder of Rita Curran On July 20, 1971, at around 1:30 am, 24-year-old Rita Curran was found dead in her bedroom. She had been sexually assaulted, beaten in the head, and strangled. It was estimated that Rita was killed at around midnight on July ...
04.25.2023 The Murder of Missy Bevers This week we are discussing the baffling murder of Missy Bevers, a loving mother of three children, with a passion for helping others. Research assistance by Anna Luria. Research by Haley Gray. Switch from the old-fashioned goo to something new! ...
04.18.2023 The Murder of Julie Jensen- Part 2 This week is part-two of a two-part story about the murder of Julie Jensen, a beloved mother, sister and friend. Julie feared her husband Mark Jensen would one day take her life, and she went so far as to write ...
04.11.2023 The Murder of Julie Jensen- Part 1 This week is part one of a two-part story about the murder of Julie Jensen, a beloved mother, sister and friend. Julie feared her husband Mark Jensen would one day take her life, and she went so far as to ...
04.04.2023 The Disappearance of Tracy Ocasio This week we are discussing the disappearance of Tracy Ocasio and the man thought to be responsible for her murder. Make sure to check out the promo for Live, Laugh, Larceny! Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. New ...
03.28.2023 Anthony Gignac: The Prince of Fraud This week we are discussing Anthony Gignac, a con artist who spent years posing as various Saudi princes in order to swindle millions of dollars from businesses and people. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. From Last Thing ...
03.21.2023 The Murder of CJ Sayers This week we are discussing the murder of CJ Sayers, a beloved son, brother, and father. Special thanks this week to the Sayers Family, who were so kind and helpful in putting together this episode on CJ. Thanks as well ...
03.14.2023 The Murder of Ramon Novarro This week we are discussing the tragic murder of Ramón Novarro, one of the first Latin American actors to make it big in Hollywood. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. New merch! Check out Moms and Mysteries Threadless! ...
03.07.2023 The Murders of Andy and Jamie Schliepsiek This week we are discussing Andy and Jamie Schliepsiek, who were murdered during a brutal attack on Robins Air Force Base. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. Link for episode discussed in Last Thing Before We Go: Big ...
02.28.2023 Murder on the High Seas This week we are discussing the horrific quadruple murder that occurred aboard the Joe Cool, a 47 foot charter yacht. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. New merch! Check out Moms and Mysteries Threadless! You can also get ...
02.21.2023 The Murder of Nancy DePriest This week we are discussing Nancy DePriest, a young wife and mother who loved life, and the two men who were wrongfully convicted of her murder. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. New merch! Check out Moms and ...
02.14.2023 The Murder of Ashleigh Love This week we are discussing the tragic murder of Ashleigh Love, a sweet, kind, and intelligent 19-year-old who is deeply missed by all who knew her. A huge thank-you to Kyle Olson with Love and Justice Podcast, as well as ...
02.07.2023 The Murder of Brittanee Drexel This week, we are discussing Brittanee Drexel, a strong-minded and independent young woman whose life was taken by a man whom the police had suspected almost immediately after her disappearance, but he wouldn't be charged with her murder for over ...
01.31.2023 Burt Pugach and Linda Riss This week we are discussing Burt Pugach and Linda Riss, who married 14 years after Burt was convicted of hiring three men to maim Linda with lye. Check-out tickets for our first Moment at www.moment.co/momsandmysteries Research by Haley Gray with ...
01.24.2023 The Death of Denisha Montgomery-Smith This week we are discussing the death of Army Pfc. Denisha Montgomery-Smith was a mother of three known for her headstrong and caring nature. Thank you to Margot with Military Murder for allowing us to collaborate on this episode. Check ...
01.17.2023 The Murder of Irene Garza This week we are discussing the murder of Irene Garza, a beloved teacher and pillar in her community and the decades it took to prosecute her killer. Check-out pre-sale tickets for our first Moment at www.moment.co/momsandmysteries Research by Haley Gray ...
01.10.2023 The Murder of Andrew Kissel This week we are discussing Andrew Kissel, a real estate developer who was murdered four days before he was scheduled to plead guilty to bank fraud. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. Research assistance by Anna Luria. Thank ...
01.03.2023 The Murder of Robert Kissel This week we are discussing the murder of Robert Kissel, a loving father of three, at the hands of his wife Nancy Kissel. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. Research assistance by Anna Luria. Thank you to our ...
12.27.2022 The Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum Heist- Replay ***We are off this week (back on January 3, 2023), so we wanted to play an episode you either haven't heard or maybe just don't remember. This week we are discussing the greatest art heist in history and the mystery ...
12.20.2022 The Murder of Steven Beard- Replay ***We are off this week and next (back on January 3, 2023), so we wanted to play two episodes you either haven't heard, or maybe don't remember. This week we are discussing the murder of a man in Texas, and ...
12.13.2022 The Murder of Raymond McNeil This week we are discussing how Sally McNeil shot and killed her husband of eight years, Ray McNeil, on Valentine’s Day 1995. Sally claimed to have killed Ray in self-defense, citing years of abuse at the hands of Ray. But ...
12.06.2022 The Murder of Larry McNabney + Update This week we are going back into the vault and replaying an episode from March of 2020 while we work on this super-size episode for next week. This week we are re-telling the story of a well-known attorney in Nevada ...
11.29.2022 The Murder of Bianca Rudolph This week we are discussing the death of Bianca Rudolph, who was shot and killed while she and her husband, Larry Rudolph, were on a safari hunt in Africa. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. Thank you to ...
11.24.2022 Amazon Presents: Killer Psyche Daily When a shocking crime occurs, former FBI Profiler Candice DeLong will have a lot to say about it. On KILLER PSYCHE DAILY, Candice digs into the motivations and behaviors of the criminal masterminds and killers who are dominating the headlines. ...
11.22.2022 The Murder of Jared Bridegan-Replay and AD-FREE Re-Play Episode: We need your help in an on-going murder investigation out of Jacksonville, Florida. Jared Bridegan was a devoted and loving husband and father, but on the night of February 16, 2022, he was shot in front of his ...
11.15.2022 The Disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit This week we are discussing the disappearance of a woman who went missing shortly before her early morning shift as a local news anchor in Mason City, Iowa. Anyone with information on Jodi’s case can reach out to the Mason ...
11.08.2022 The Chippendales Murder: The Murder of Nick De Noia This week we’re discussing the dark side of the Chippendales and the man who let jealousy ruin his legacy. Research by Haley Gray with Haley Gray Research. To get 15% off your next gift, go to www.uncommongoods.com/momsandmurder. Don’t miss out ...
11.04.2022 Cold Season 3: The Search for Sheree Sheree Warren left her job in Salt Lake City on a mild October evening in 1985. She told a coworker she was headed to meet her estranged husband, Charles Warren, at a car dealership. But she never made it, Sheree ...

Older episodes