Riffology: Iconic Rock Albums Podcast

RIFF063 - Anthrax - Persistence of Time


Listen Later

When Anthrax grew up but kept the chops

Joey Belladonna's last stand before a 19-year hiatus delivered Anthrax at their most mature—darker lyrics tackling social justice and mortality, mid-tempo grooves that hit harder than pure speed, and production that finally matched the Big Four's best. From the ticking-clock intro of "Time" to the Joe Jackson cover that somehow makes perfect sense, Persistence of Time proved the New York thrashers could evolve without losing their edge. Neil wears his commitment on his sleeve (literally—bought the t-shirt twice after wearing it until the arms fell off), while the episode careens from Charlie Benante's unusual drummer-writes-guitar-riffs setup to a Fruit Pastilles crisis at Sainsbury's and the glorious teenage logic of punching a VCR because it ate your dad's Queen video.

Recorded December '89–February '90 at A&M and Conway Studios in Hollywood, mixed by Steve Thompson and Michael Barbiero at Electric Lady, and mastered by Bob Ludwig, this is Anthrax stepping up sonically while keeping Scott Ian's deliberate down-picking and Charlie's uber-precise drumming front and center. It's the bridge between State of Euphoria's happy major chords and Sound of White Noise's John Bush darkness—a 58:40 thrash record where 6-7 minute tracks don't feel long and social commentary cuts through without lectures.

What You'll Hear
  • Big Four context reimagined: Why Anthrax never quite fit the thrash mold—too light-hearted for the scene, but this album shifts the tone completely
  • Production evolution dissected: Mark Dodson produced State of Euphoria too, but this sounds radically different—Thompson/Barbiero's mix at Hendrix's Electric Lady Studios, Bob Ludwig's master
  • Unique songwriting dynamic: Charlie Benante (the drummer) writes guitar riffs, Scott Ian adds rhythm and lyrics, Joey sings—an unusual creative setup that shaped the vocal range requirements
  • Joey's final chapter (part one): His operatic high-register vocals peak here before the 1992 split, then rusty 2011 return on Worship Music, and triumphant For All Kings Barrowlands recording
  • Live passion undiminished: 40th anniversary tour emotions, the curtain-drop video tribute from Metallica/Exodus/Judas Priest, Frank Bello as photographer's dream orangutan, Rock City perfection at 2000 capacity
  • Tangential gold unlimited: The Barry Milner Bridge heritage campaign (TripAdvisor reviews, Google Maps registration, calls for band name/Joe Jackson statue/flag), VCR programming nightmares (Grundig clicky-clacky vs Hitachi touch buttons, Tommy Vance rock show at 3am, dad switching off the Cinderella recording), and the Queen Greatest Flicks tape-chewing VCR-punching incident that seemed "perfectly reasonable" at the time
  • Featured Tracks

    Singles "In My World" (Neil's favorite—mid-tempo deliberate Scott Ian down-picking showcase) and "Got the Time" (Joe Jackson cover with Swaddlincote bass intro connection) demonstrate the album's range, while "Keep It in the Family" delivers hidden-gem epic riffage with powerful social justice lyrics and the H8Red wordplay that took Neil 10 years to realize meant "hatred" (maths student didn't do language). The 58:40 runtime feels effortless despite tracks running 6-7 minutes—dynamics move from Blood to Gridlock without flab, embracing mid-tempo heft that Metallica's Black Album, Slayer's Seasons, and Megadeth's Rust in Peace were all exploring simultaneously. First instrumental "Intro to Reality" features Twilight Zone dialogue, while Japanese edition bonus "Protestants Survive" (Discharge cover) includes Charlie Benante's backwards message quiz—removed from 2007 reprints making the original "uber rare."

    Tangential Gold
    • Barry Milner Bridge heritage crusade: Moira, Swaddlincote, South Derbyshire heritage site gets TripAdvisor reviews from locals, registered on Google Maps, campaign calling for band name/Joe Jackson statue/flag hanging—UK compatriot context absolutely brilliant
    • "Taping is killing the music industry": 1980s LP back warning stickers pre-MP3 Napster, VHS FBI warnings about recording programs, the full nightmare of VCR programming with top-loader indecipherable buttons vs better Japanese touch-button models
    • Tommy Vance rock show trauma: 2-3am recordings, trying to program the VCR, waking to find dad switched it off, the dead-excited Cinderella new album recording lost forever, no one else had Cinderella so really wanted it
    • The Queen video punch: Greatest Flicks burgundy double VHS set, learning "Bohemian Rhapsody" solo with pause/rewind, tape overheated and chewed, teenager logic—punched the VCR because it did bad thing, smashed video player to bits, then had to explain to dad the "perfectly reasonable" response, not only replace dad's favorite Queen video but replace whole video recorder
    • CD wallet confessions: 200+ backup CDs, "Lars Ulrich would disapprove," the piracy crime era before streaming killed the music industry differently
    • Why This Matters

      This is the transitional Anthrax moment—Joey Belladonna's peak before 19 years away, the production step-up that proved they belonged sonically with the Big Four's best, the darker mature lyrical shift from State of Euphoria's happiness to introspective social commentary. It's also the album that reveals Anthrax's unusual creative engine (drummer writes guitar!), captures their live passion that persists four decades later, and sits perfectly between the happy thrash past and John Bush's darker future. Released August 21, 1990, it hit #24 on Billboard 200, went gold, got Grammy-nominated, toured for 18 months, spawned a Married… with Children crossover episode, and influenced the mid-tempo evolution across thrash before grunge and nu-metal arrived. The tangential moments—from heritage site campaigns to VCR teenage destruction—remind us that music fandom lives in the obsessive details and ridiculous stories, not just the riffs.

      Perfect for

      Joey Belladonna loyalists preparing for the Sound of White Noise comparison; Big Four completists who respect Anthrax's refusal to fit the mold; production nerds fascinated by Electric Lady Studios and the Thompson/Barbiero/Ludwig dream team; songwriting students intrigued by drummers writing guitar riffs; live-music devotees who believe 2000-capacity venues beat stadiums; anyone who's ever punched inanimate objects in teenage fury and later questioned the logic; VCR programming survivors; heritage campaign enthusiasts; people who realize "H8Red" wordplay a decade late; and fans who measure album commitment in t-shirts worn until structural failure.

      You can find us here:
      • Blog: https://riffology.co
      • All Episodes: https://podkit.riffology.co/podcast
      • iHeart: https://www.iheart.com/podcast/1323-riffology-iconic-rock-alb-176865775
      • Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/riffology-iconic-rock-albums-podcast/id1691556696
      • Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/1LIU9mein7QMw346q20nyy
      • X: https://x.com/RiffologyPod
      • Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/riffology.co
      • Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/riffology
      • ...more
        View all episodesView all episodes
        Download on the App Store

        Riffology: Iconic Rock Albums PodcastBy Riffology