Serialholic Sisters: True Crime Shit

By Samantha and Krystal

What's Serialholic Sisters: True Crime Shit about?

Settle in and get all cozy with your morning coffee or your end of the day cocktail and just hang out and listen to two awkward sisters, sitting around talking about true crime shit.

Download our free app to listen on your phone

Serialholic Sisters: True Crime Shit episodes:

10.25.2023
119. The Unsolved Murder of JonBenet Ramsey: Part 2
Part 2 is out! Settle in and get comfy cozy while Krystal concludes the unsolved murder of Jonbenet Ramsey. In Part 1 we discussed the “kidnapping”, autopsy, and blundering investigation of this case. In this episode we’ll look a little...
09.28.2023
118. The Unsolved Murder of JonBenet Ramsey: Part 1
Hey Serialholics! We want to thank y’all for understanding while we took some time for family matters. We’re so excited to be back and to get back to our “normal”. This one is gonna be a long one, so long...
08.10.2023
117. Donna Doll: All The Potato Talk
This week Samantha covers the unsolved murder of Donna Doll. Donna was a 21 year old college student that suddenly went missing in October of 1970. When she was found over a week later, her autopsy revealed some mind blowing...
07.27.2023
116. Tyler Hadley: The Tragic Murders of Mary Jo and Blake Hadley
This week Krystal covers the tragic murders of Mary Jo and Blake Hadley. As parents we have so many fears about our children, from the time they’re newborns until they’re grown, we worry about them and their safety nonstop. The...
07.14.2023
115. Libby German and Abby Williams: The Delphi Murders
This week Samantha covers the unsolved/possibly solved case of the Delphi murders. Join us as we discuss the tragic murders of 13 and 14-year-old best friends Abby Williams and Libby German and the various sketchy suspects/possible murderer. --- Send in a...
06.29.2023
114. Arthur Shawcross: The Genesee River Killer
We’re back! Thank y’all for your support and patience and all the good vibes sent our way while we took a break to deal with life things. Now, settle in as Krystal covers Arthur Shawcross aka the Genesee River Killer...
04.13.2023
113. The Watcher: Why Are You So Obsessed With This House?
We’re back! Thank you all for your patience and the good vibes sent our way while Samantha continues to recover from surgery. Now, settle in as she covers the creepy case of the Watcher. This guy (or possibly gal) terrorized...
03.23.2023
112. The Horrific Hi-Fi Shop Murders: That’s Not How You Rob A Store
Join us as Krystal covers the Hi-Fi murders. On April 22, 1974 six men decided to rob a local home audio store. Two of those men took this plan from run of the mill robbery to the horrific murders it...
03.09.2023
111. Chicago Tylenol Murders: Don’t Trust Anything
Join us as Samantha covers the insane case of the Chicago Tylenol Murders. In the early 1980’s, someone filled multiple bottles of Tylenol capsules with deadly cyanide, and placed them on store shelves for anyone to purchase. This one is...
02.16.2023
Episode 110. Susan Walters: The Epitome of Badassery
Join us as Krystal covers the unbelievably badass survival story of Susan Walters. 51-year-old Susan is the definition of badassery, and is what we aspire to be when we grow up! Also, please excuse our audio at the beginning of the...
02.02.2023
Episode 109. The Tragic Case of Gypsy Rose and Dee Dee Blanchard
Join us as Samantha covers the life of Gypsy Rose Blanchard and the murder of Dee Dee Blanchard. This case is tragic from beginning to end, in so many different ways-from the emotional, mental, and physical abuse Gypsy endured from...
01.12.2023
Episode 108. Holly Bobo: We Have So Many Questions
This week Krystal covers the abduction and murder of Holly Bobo. 20-year-old Holly was getting into her car to go to a nursing school exam when she was abducted at her own house, taken into the woods by a man...
12.29.2022
Episode 107. The Abduction and Murder of Jodi Sanderholm: Stalked By A Monster
This week Samantha covers a case close to home. Jodi Sanderholm was unknowingly stalked for years before she was suddenly abducted in broad daylight, beaten, sexually assaulted, and brutally murdered by her stalker. All the trigger warnings for this one...
12.11.2022
Episode 106. The Bloody Benders: Murder..They Were Doing It
We’re back! This week Krystal is in the holiday spirit and covers a case about what the holidays are truly about. Family. But this isn’t your typical family. This week we’re talking about the first documented serial killing family in...
11.17.2022
Episode 105. Michelle Hadley: The Case Of The Most Crazy Exes
This week Samantha covers the case of the craziest of exes. Michelle Hadley was just trying to go on about life after ending and engagement to a controlling narcissist when Mr. Crazy Ex and and his new wife go insane...
11.03.2022
Episode 104. Belle Gunness: Bills Bills Bills
Spooky season is over (according to the calendar but not our dark souls
10.31.2022
Episode 103. This Is Halloween: The Third
This is Halloween…the third! Episode 103 is out and it’s our 3rd Halloween special! Join us as we creep each other out while telling some spooky listener tales! --- Send in a voice message: https://anchor.fm/serialholicsisters/message
10.20.2022
Episode 102. William Beadle: Thou Shalt Not Kill *(yo-self or others)
We have a special guest for Episode 102! This week Shannon graces us with her wonderful presence and tells us all about the case of the first documented mass murder/suicide..her VERY distant relative William Beadle. --- Send in a voice...
10.06.2022
Episode 101. The Unsolved Slash “Solved” McStay Family Disappearance
This week Samantha covers the crazy unsolved and then “solved” disappearance and murder of the McStay Family. This case really gets you thinking…and questioning its conclusion. --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/serialholicsisters/message
09.22.2022
Episode 100. Charlie Manson:The Ultimate Hippie Cult Leader, Ya Dig?
It’s our 100th episode! We wanted to deliver a big case for you for this episode, so this week Krystal reaches into her inner hippie and covers crazy ass cult leader, Charles Manson. Much like Charlie, this case is all...
09.08.2022
Episode 99. Stacey Castor: World’s Worst Wife/Mother
This week Samantha covers the crazy case of Stacey Castor, also known as the Black Widow. If you were married to Stacey, things didn’t look great for you. Both of her husbands ended up dead, and even her own daughter...
08.18.2022
Episode 98. David and Catherine Birnie:The Moorehouse Murders
This week Krystal covers Australia’s most notorious serial killer couple David and Catherine Birnie. This couple had an extremely toxic and codependent relationship, and together they abducted, raped, and murdered young women across the Perth area. --- Send in a voice...
08.04.2022
Episode 97. The Reinert Murders: So Many Red Flags
This week Samantha covers the mysterious Reinert Murders. This one is a doozy, filled with questionable people, affairs, drugs, womanizers, red flags, and unanswered questions. We’ll, really just one unanswered question…what happened to the Reinert kids??? --- Send in a voice...
07.14.2022
Episode 96. Dennis Rader: The Average To Below Average Killer
This week Krystal covers possibly the most obnoxious serial killer, Dennis Rader. Settle in and get ready for lots of eye rolls because this guy is a bumbling idiot, and it makes no sense to us that it took 30...
06.30.2022
Episode 95. Cassie Jo Stoddart: The Copycat Scream Murder
This week Samantha covers a copycat case. She tells us all about the murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart aka the Scream murder. Brian Draper and Torrey Adamcik were so obsessed with Scream that they based their murder on this movie...
06.23.2022
Episode 94. Tommy Lynn Sells: You Don't Get To Make Up Your Own Nickname…You Nozzle
This week Krystal covers…kind of a continuation of last week’s case, but not really. Tommy Lynn Sells is literally the worst. Not only is he a lying liar that loves lying, he’s the absolute worst kind of serial killer out...
06.16.2022
Episode 93. A Quadruple Unsolved Homicide: The Dardeen Family Murders
This week Samantha covers a gruesome quadruple homicide, the brutal murders of the Dardeen family. Even though a convicted serial killer claimed to have murdered this family, this chilling case remains unsolved. --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/serialholicsisters/message
06.16.2022
Episode 77. The Mary Morris Murders: The Worst Hitman Ever
This week Samantha covers the Mary Morris murders. This one is a real head scratcher…was it a crazy coincidence or the world’s worst hitman? Let us know what you think! --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/serialholicsisters/message
06.16.2022
Episode 78. Richard Ramirez: The Biggest Tool Ever
This week Krystal covers the biggest tool ever, the one and only Richard Ramirez. Ramirez terrorized California in the mid 80’s, and with no distinct MO to follow, no one was safe from his chaotic crime spree. --- Send in a...
06.09.2022
Episode 92. The Torture and Murder of Kelly-Anne Bates
This week Krystal covers the torture and murder of Kelly-Anne Bates, and the shag monster that murdered her, James Patterson Smith. 45-year-old Smith groomed 17-year-old Kelly-Anne, eventually torturing and abusing her for over a straight month before tragically ending her...
05.26.2022
Episode 91. Blake Leibel: The Entitled Graphic Novelist
This week Samantha covers the gruesome torture and murder of Iana Kasain and her murderer, the entitled Hollywood producer and graphic novelist Blake Leibel. This case is gnarly, unprecedented, and completely heartbreaking. --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/serialholicsisters/message
05.19.2022
Episode 90. Carl Tanzler: Count Creepy Carl Von Cosel
This week Krystal tells us a love story. Okay, not really…this is a true crime podcast y’all. But if you were to ask Carl Tanzler, he would tell you this is a love story for the ages. In reality, this...
05.12.2022
Episode 89. Who Murdered Marilyn Sheppard?
This week Samantha covers the mysterious murder of Marilyn Sheppard. This case is is wild and has us questioning who murdered Marilyn? Was is her husband, a ghost, a hired window washer, or the mayor’s wife? --- Send in a...
05.05.2022
Episode 88. Andre Thomas: Why Was Nobody Watching Him?
This week Krystal covers Andre Thomas. This one is infuriating… it’s another family murder case that could have been completely avoided by proper mental health treatment. Please, if you are or you see someone struggling, seek help. --- Send in a...
04.28.2022
Episode 87. The Stayner Brothers: Mufasa and Scar
This week Samantha covers two cases all wrapped in one, the Stayner brothers. One is a hero, the other is…the opposite of a hero, yet they both end up having tragic tales. --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/serialholicsisters/message
04.21.2022
Episode 86. Andrea Yates: The Yates Family Murders
This week Krystal covers Andrea Yates. This case is truly horrific, and one of the most heavy/difficult to research that I’ve come across so far. It brings up the discussion of the importance of mental health care and made us...
04.14.2022
Episode 85. John Joubert: The Toolbag Plonker Nozzle
This week Samantha tells us all about John Joubert. This guy is a piece of work. With an IQ of 123 you would think he would know the difference between right and wrong, but he must be all book smarts...
04.07.2022
Episode 84. The Disappearance and Murder of Annie Le
This week Krystal covers the disappearance and murder of Annie Le. Annie was a Yale student who was working on world changing research when she was tragically assaulted and murdered by this plonker, Raymond Clark III. --- Send in a voice...
03.31.2022
Episode 83. Chuck Morgan: The Ozark National Treasure Sopranos Good Girls Case
This week Samantha covers the strange death of Chuck Morgan, or as we like to call it, the Ozark/ National Treasure/Sopranos/Good Girls case. Was it suicide or murder? And who is Green Eyes? --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/serialholicsisters/message
03.24.2022
Episode 82. Dennis Nilsen: The Off-brand Jeffrey Dahmer
This week Krystal tells us all about the British Jeffrey Dahmer, Dennis Nilsen. This one is rough guys, there’s a reason this guy got this nickname, even though he was arrested before Dahmer. --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/serialholicsisters/message
03.17.2022
Episode 81. The Jamison Family Weird Unsolved True Crime Murder Possibly Case
This week Samantha covers the Jamison family weird unsolved true crime murder possibly case. Her words, not mine. Seriously, we can’t figure out what happened here. Let us know your thoughts! --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/serialholicsisters/message
03.10.2022
Episode 80. The Murder of Susan Jordan
This week Krystal covers the murder of Susan Jordan and the piece of garbage that murdered her, Albert Greenwood Brown. Y’all. This is one of the most infuriating cases that I’ve ever covered. --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/serialholicsisters/message
03.03.2022
Episode 79. Jeffrey Dahmer: AKA Vomitous Little Weasle
This week Samantha covers one of the most vomitous weasels ever, Jeffrey Dahmer. This monster is well known as one of the most prolific serial killers of all time and committed so many horrendous unspeakable crimes. --- Send in a...
02.17.2022
Episode 78. Richard Ramirez: The Biggest Tool Ever
This week Krystal covers the biggest tool ever, the one and only Richard Ramirez. Ramirez terrorized California in the mid 80’s, and with no distinct MO to follow, no one was safe from his chaotic crime spree. --- Send in a...
02.07.2022
Episode 77. The Mary Morris Murders: The Worst Hitman Ever
This week Samantha covers the Mary Morris murders. This one is a real head scratcher…was it a crazy coincidence or the world’s worst hitman? Let us know what you think! --- Send in a voice message: https://anchor.fm/serialholicsisters/message
01.31.2022
Episode 76. The Gainesville Ripper: Hold Me Closer Tony Danza
This week Krystal covers Danny Rolling and the brutal Gainesville Ripper murders. This one gets pretty rough and is actually the real life case that the very first Scream movie was loosely based off of. Shoutout to our little bro...
01.24.2022
Episode 75. Mia Zapata: The 27 Club Murder
This week Samantha covers the tragic murder of punk rocker Mia Zapata. She and her band The Gits were just beginning to make a name for themselves in the rock world when her life was tragically ended. --- Send in...
01.16.2022
Episode 74. The Kunz Family Murders: So Many Questions
Welcome to our Covid edition. That’s right, we both have Covid. So, what better way to spend our isolation than recording new episodes for y'all! This week Krystal covers the Kunz family murders, and we want to hear your thoughts...
01.10.2022
Episode 73. Michelle Martinko: Cold Case Turned Warm Case
Settle in as Samantha covers the cold case turned warm case of the murder of Michelle Martinko…and we realize just how bad Krystal is at guessing a good ol’ fashioned whodunnit. --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/serialholicsisters/message
01.03.2022
Episode 72. The Kidnapping and Murder of Polly Klaas
Happy New Year, y’all! May this year be better than the last! This week Krystal covers the kidnapping and murder of Polly Klaas and the piece of wet lettuce that was responsible, Richard Allen Davis. We want to punch this...

What's Serialholic Sisters: True Crime Shit about?

Download our free app to listen on your phone

Serialholic Sisters: True Crime Shit episodes:

119. The Unsolved Murder of JonBenet Ramsey: Part 2

118. The Unsolved Murder of JonBenet Ramsey: Part 1

117. Donna Doll: All The Potato Talk

116. Tyler Hadley: The Tragic Murders of Mary Jo and Blake Hadley

115. Libby German and Abby Williams: The Delphi Murders

114. Arthur Shawcross: The Genesee River Killer

113. The Watcher: Why Are You So Obsessed With This House?

112. The Horrific Hi-Fi Shop Murders: That’s Not How You Rob A Store

111. Chicago Tylenol Murders: Don’t Trust Anything

Episode 110. Susan Walters: The Epitome of Badassery

Episode 109. The Tragic Case of Gypsy Rose and Dee Dee Blanchard

Episode 108. Holly Bobo: We Have So Many Questions

Episode 107. The Abduction and Murder of Jodi Sanderholm: Stalked By A Monster

Episode 106. The Bloody Benders: Murder..They Were Doing It

Episode 105. Michelle Hadley: The Case Of The Most Crazy Exes

Episode 104. Belle Gunness: Bills Bills Bills

Episode 103. This Is Halloween: The Third

Episode 102. William Beadle: Thou Shalt Not Kill *(yo-self or others)

Episode 101. The Unsolved Slash “Solved” McStay Family Disappearance

Episode 100. Charlie Manson:The Ultimate Hippie Cult Leader, Ya Dig?

Episode 99. Stacey Castor: World’s Worst Wife/Mother

Episode 98. David and Catherine Birnie:The Moorehouse Murders

Episode 97. The Reinert Murders: So Many Red Flags

Episode 96. Dennis Rader: The Average To Below Average Killer

Episode 95. Cassie Jo Stoddart: The Copycat Scream Murder

Episode 94. Tommy Lynn Sells: You Don't Get To Make Up Your Own Nickname…You Nozzle

Episode 93. A Quadruple Unsolved Homicide: The Dardeen Family Murders

Episode 77. The Mary Morris Murders: The Worst Hitman Ever

Episode 78. Richard Ramirez: The Biggest Tool Ever

Episode 92. The Torture and Murder of Kelly-Anne Bates

Episode 91. Blake Leibel: The Entitled Graphic Novelist

Episode 90. Carl Tanzler: Count Creepy Carl Von Cosel

Episode 89. Who Murdered Marilyn Sheppard?

Episode 88. Andre Thomas: Why Was Nobody Watching Him?

Episode 87. The Stayner Brothers: Mufasa and Scar

Episode 86. Andrea Yates: The Yates Family Murders

Episode 85. John Joubert: The Toolbag Plonker Nozzle

Episode 84. The Disappearance and Murder of Annie Le

Episode 83. Chuck Morgan: The Ozark National Treasure Sopranos Good Girls Case

Episode 82. Dennis Nilsen: The Off-brand Jeffrey Dahmer

Episode 81. The Jamison Family Weird Unsolved True Crime Murder Possibly Case

Episode 80. The Murder of Susan Jordan

Episode 79. Jeffrey Dahmer: AKA Vomitous Little Weasle

Episode 78. Richard Ramirez: The Biggest Tool Ever

Episode 77. The Mary Morris Murders: The Worst Hitman Ever

Episode 76. The Gainesville Ripper: Hold Me Closer Tony Danza

Episode 75. Mia Zapata: The 27 Club Murder

Episode 74. The Kunz Family Murders: So Many Questions

Episode 73. Michelle Martinko: Cold Case Turned Warm Case

Episode 72. The Kidnapping and Murder of Polly Klaas