Small Town Murder

By James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman

Society & Culture Comedy

What's Small Town Murder about?

Two comedians look at a small town, what makes it tick, and a murder that took place there. In depth research, horrible tragedy, and the hosts' comedic spin on the whole thing. New episodes every Thursday!!

4.9

54,178 ratings

Download our free app to listen on your phone

LAST EPISODE

#442 - The Social Media Lov...

11.25.2023

This week, in Joppatowne, Maryland, a college student begins to display some very strange, and concerning behavior, violently attacking a fellow student, and making some of the weirdest social media posts, ever. This escalates quickly, and before you know it, ...

Small Town Murder episodes:

11.25.2023 #442 - The Social Media Loving Cannibal - Joppatowne, Maryland This week, in Joppatowne, Maryland, a college student begins to display some very strange, and concerning behavior, violently attacking a fellow student, and making some of the weirdest social media posts, ever. This escalates quickly, and before you know it, ...
11.23.2023 #441 - Bashed, Slashed & Scattered - Fillmore, Utah This week, in Fillmore, Utah, a young lady, who is happy to stand up for herself when needed, goes on a trip, and ends up hitchhiking, and is never seen alive, again. When she is finally found, it's as awful ...
11.18.2023 #440 - A Character Of Evil - Airdrie, Alberta, Canada This week, in Airdrie, Alberta, Canada, a strange hatred, and need of revenge boils inside of a very odd man, for years. It starts out as a nationwide mystery, but ends up as one of the most brutal & disturbing ...
11.16.2023 #439 - Did The Dog Do It? - Dillsboro, Indiana This week, in Dillsboro, Indiana, when a very tough, but gentle man is allegedly murdered... by his dog, police are suspicious of the story. Detectives are even more suspicious, when they find a coffin sized box, on the property, that ...
11.11.2023 #438 - An Officer & Three Maniacs - Biloxi, Mississippi This week, in Biloxi, Mississippi, when a rough teenaged divorcee/bartender/dancer gets angry about her relationship with a older man not working out, she forms a team, including another teenager, and a man, who lives in his car. This leads to ...
11.09.2023 #437 - Sex, Greed & Vice Principals - Toms River Township, New Jersey This week, in Toms River Township, New Jersey, a wild & cruel conspiracy is the only explanation when one member of an important, well liked local couple is brutally killed. An affair with the local high school vice principal is ...
11.03.2023 #436 - The Unraveling Of A Psychopath - Windsor, Wisconsin This week, in Windsor, Wisconsin, it's a huge mystery, when a happy, and successful couple seem to disappear into thin air. While their seemingly clean cut, well adjusted young adult children beg the police for help, detectives use a jealous ...
11.02.2023 #435 - Laughing, Torture & Lies - Gans, Oklahoma This week, in Gans , Oklahoma, a woman, with a strange past, decides to take matters into her own hands when she believes that her son's ex girlfriend is setting him up to be busted by the cops, or even ...
10.27.2023 #434 - A Nearly Headless Horror Scene - Pemberton, West Virginia This week, in Pemberton, West Virginia, a crazy day in a neighborhood of trailers, starting with one man, snorting pills & drinking cheap whiskey, before noon. He ends up at an odd "party", where he gets into an argument, over ...
10.26.2023 #433 - A Ghost With A Samurai Sword - Willington, Connecticut This week, in Willington, Connecticut, a seemingly studious, and polite young man appears to absolutely snap, when he goes on a rampage, across the state, starting with writing odd things on his walls, then carving someone up with a samurai ...
10.20.2023 #432 - Broken Trust, Broken Skull - Elko, Nevada This week, in Elko, Nevada, a ranch hand, who everyone calls "Turkey", with a shady history goes missing, and everyone thinks he just took off. Until he's found face down in a river. The evidence says he's been there for ...
10.19.2023 #431 - My Daddybrother Did It - Clayton, Georgia This week, in Clayton, Georgia, a family with a violent criminal history seems to explode over some very unconventional relationships, jealously, and custody battles. This results in one of the strangest marriages, that causes much drama within the family. One ...
10.13.2023 #430 - Naked Aggression & Vicious Violence - Paducah, Kentucky This week, in Paducah, Kentucky, a wild affair turns into an even wilder relationship, with countless stories of strange behavior, including drunkenly running around an RV park, while naked, then attacking the responding cop with a steel rod, and stabbings ...
10.12.2023 #429 - A Clean Cut Serial Killer - Manhattan, Montana This week, in Manhattan, Montana, a series of disappearances don't seem to raise any red flags for the local police. Finally, after the fourth victim goes missing, the FBI decide that it just may be what will soon be known ...
10.06.2023 #428 - Weak Motives & Wilderness Gangsters - Palmer, Alaska This week, in Palmer, Alaska, a teenager, with a good future, heads to hang out with an old friend, and classmate, but never makes hit home. The whole area searches frantically, but when the teenager is finally found, it's worse ...
10.05.2023 #427 - Fat Sam & Crazy Crystal - Lawrenceburg, Tennessee This week, in Lawrenceburg, Tennessee, an unlikely, but deadly situation unfolds, after an absolute bloodbath is discovered. There are many suspects, including a slew of local dirtbags, drug dealers, and even the mafia. But some dark secrets are discovered in ...
09.29.2023 #426 - The Chief, The Floozie & The Church Lady - Lyons, Nebraska This week, in Lyons, Nebraska, the new woman in town seems to be a non drinking, moralistic church person, until it's revealed that there's also an affair with her neighbor, the Chief of the town's police force, ever since they ...
09.28.2023 #425 - Strange Morals & Stranger Sexual Needs - Atascocita, Texas This week, in Atoscocita, Texas, new desires, including some odd sexual demands cause a relationship to fall apart, and have the whole thing turn into a ridiculous murder plot. This involves crazy schemes, and many people, including a man, asking ...
09.22.2023 #424 - The Bloodiest Present Under The Tree - Crystal, Minnesota This week, in Crystal, Minnesota, an alcoholic couple seem to stumble through each day, before drinking so much, that they pass out at night. This caused some obvious problems, but it all comes to a head, one day, a week ...
09.21.2023 #423 - The Killer Has Something In His Pants - Walsenburg, Colorado This week, in Walsenburg, Colorado, the whole area panics, when a man is found in front of his house, very bloody, and barely conscious. But his real concern is his wife, who turns out to be dead, in the kitchen. ...
09.17.2023 #425 - COMING SOON! Your Stupid Opinions Join comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman with their new podcast as they explore the most opinionated part of the internet: The Reviews Section! Get ready for the premiere of Your Stupid Opinions... September 18, 2023. Subscribe and we will ...
09.15.2023 #422 - Dead In A Ditch - Claymont, Delaware This week, in Claymont, Delaware, when a missing man is found, beaten to death, in a ditch, there are some clues, but the case quickly goes cold. Until a tip to detectives unravels a complex plan, involving baseball bats, an ...
09.14.2023 #421 - Three Murders & Six Congenital Idiots - Starke, Florida This week, in Starke, Florida, a woman tries to help her sister find someone to scare the sister's husband into an easier custody battle. This leads to an ex-Marine, turned mercenary, who advertises his services in a magazine. Of course, ...
09.08.2023 #420 - Cheating, Lies & Corn Rakes - Earlville, Iowa This week, in Earlville, Iowa, problems enter the marriage of a farm couple, leading to cheating, and many hurt feelings. Tensions simmer, under the surface, and this all ends with someone having a large corn rake stuck in their back, ...
09.07.2023 #419 - A Major Lack Of Aloha - Hilo, Hawaii This week, in Hilo, Hawaii, a young woman, who has dreamed of Hawaii her entire life, moves to the big island, with tragic results. A simple Christmas Eve bike ride, along a scenic ocean road, ends in finding one shoe, ...
09.01.2023 #418 - The Stranger & The Psychic - Scarborough, Maine This week, in Scarborough, Maine, a missing young woman sends the area into a panic, but things get even worse, when she's found. The investigation reveals some strange facts, but it comes down to being between three different suspects, her ...
08.31.2023 #417 - No Body, No Crime... Except For That Head - Hazelton, Idaho This week, in Hazelton, Idaho, after a marital break up everything seems fine, with both parties, moving on, an progressing in their lives. But one person is absolutely holding a grudge, and a small thing sets them off. Next thing ...
08.25.2023 #416 - The Incredible Disappearing Head - North Canton, Ohio This week, in North Canton, Ohio, the paths of two very different people cross in a strange little trailer park. One of these people is an ex-Marine, turned hairdresser, with a long history of violence, and generally crazy behavior. The ...
08.24.2023 #415 - Dirty Desires, Killer Consequences - Columbia, Illinois This week, in Columbia, Illinois, the perfect couple have the perfect family. In the perfect house. In the perfect town. They even have perfect jobs. But things get very imperfect when a sudden affair changes all future plans, and eventually ...
08.18.2023 #414 - Don't Anger The Princess - Bryant, Arkansas This week, in Bryant, Arkansas, a perfect little family isn't so perfect, when their teenage daughter begins to disobey, do drugs, and not listen to her parents. This causes major problems, and drama within the family, causing divorce, and untold ...
08.17.2023 #413 - Judging The Devil By His Horns - Pittsfield, Massachussets This week, in Pittsfield, Massachusetts, A very terrible man, somehow finds people just as terrible as him, including a man who has his teeth sharpened, tongue split, and has horns implanted into his forehead, to commit some of the most ...
08.11.2023 #412 - The Bloody Basement Breakfast Club - Bismarck, North Dakota This week, in Bismarck, North Dakota, one local basement is the all purpose hangout for a pair of teen sisters, their boyfriends, and several other local losers & runaways. They live there, drink, shoot meth, and plan crimes. After one ...
08.10.2023 #411 - Her Emo Eyes Have Powers - Terra Linda, California This week, in Terra Linda, California, a young lady has a very strange home life, with a seemingly mentally ill mother, who the young woman calls "Hitler". She delves into a world where she calls herself a High Priestess, and ...
08.04.2023 #410 - The Longest Night - Green River, Wyoming This week, in Green River, Wyoming, a wild night comes from a love triangle gone crazy! When two men seem to be in love with the same woman, they argue, then decide to be friends. This causes an insane scene ...
08.03.2023 #409 - Cousins, Lovers & Killers - Summerfield, North Carolina This week, in Summerfield, North Carolina, a very unlikely couple, decide to take on their families, and everyone else they feel has wronged them, with horrifying, murderous results. Why are they an unlikely couple? Because they're first cousins, from a ...
07.28.2023 #408 - Never Saw That Coming - Townshend, Vermont This week, in Townshend, Vermont, what appears to be a nice story, of a couple, living a nice life, turns very dark when it's least expected. This leaves one member of this couple brutally beaten to death, in the driveway, ...
07.27.2023 #407 - Attempted Threesomes, Russian Brides & Time Travel - Alsea, Oregon This week, in Alsea, Oregon, a man who seems to charm everyone he comes in contact with, finds love in Russia, and quickly moves to bring her to the US for marriage. What she doesn't know, is that he's already ...
07.21.2023 #406 - Not Even A Little Sorry - Flagstaff, Arizona This week, in Flagstaff, Arizona, a move across the country doesn't quite cure the relationship between a young couple, instead causing an attempted break up. This results in terribly brutal murder, complete with a horrifying final deed. Surprisingly, the not ...
07.20.2023 #405 - The Horny Teacher's Lounge - Upper Merion Township, Pennsylvania This week, in Upper Merion Township, Pennsylvania, a twisted tree of relationships, among a group of suburban high school teachers spins completely out of control, when a meek, married woman is romanced by a fellow teacher, who is seemingly irresistible ...
07.14.2023 #404 - The Laughing Psychopath - Marrero, Louisiana This week, in Marrero, Louisiana, a night of bar hopping & fun leads to a drunken group of people, driving in a car. It all turns very dark, when violence comes out of nowhere, resulting in one of the party ...
07.13.2023 #403 - Three Suspects & A Moron - Silver City, New Mexico This week, in Silver City, New Mexico, a young woman is found, brutally killed, floating in her own bathtub. The suspects include her police officer/soon to be ex-husband, her too good to be true new boyfriend, and the weirdo who ...
07.07.2023 #402 - Fornication, Forensics & French Fries - Morris, Alabama This week, in Morris, Alabama, a woman finds love, after the tragic death of her first husband, but then finds even more love, with her church's Pastor. This leads to problems in their marriages, and some messy conversations. But when ...
07.06.2023 #401 - A Seriously Crazy Cuisine - Morrice, Michigan This week, in Morrice, Michigan, a successful man, with a good job, and nice family seemingly loses his mind. He begins having strange fantasies, and losing touch with reality. From there, the story goes in a completely different direction, when ...
06.30.2023 #400 - The Bad Seed - Eureka, Utah This week, in Eureka, Utah, a man who started getting arrested at age 10, was in prison by 15, and participating in a very well known riot/murder while behind bars. Once he gets out, he's predictably primed for violence, and ...
06.29.2023 #399 - Titanic Insanity - Port Angeles, Washington This week, in Port Angeles, Washington, when it looks like the story is going one way, it takes a complete left turn into unexpected, and shocking cold bloodedness. When a woman is found, dead, in an overturned car, it becomes ...
06.23.2023 #398 - I Just Needed To See Blood - Liberty, New York This week, in Liberty, New York, a sitcom like living arrangement turns out to not be such a hilarious situation, when a mother, her grown daughter have a middle of the night confrontation that seemingly starts over loud music, dancing, ...
06.22.2023 #397 - Stunning Brutality, Shocking Stupidity - Dumfries, Virginia This week, in Dumfries, Virginia, the disappearance of a young boy, from his neighborhood produces an underwhelming police response, and the loss of vital evidence that allows an obvious monster to continue to roam the streets. This results in him, ...
06.16.2023 #396 - Sifting Through Suspects - Rock Hill, South Carolina This week, in Rock Hill, South Carolina, what appears to be a person, taking their own life, turns out to be anything but that. It's actually a cold blooded, terrifying murder that occurred when someone slipped into a home, in ...
06.15.2023 #395 - Not Answering The Call Of Duty - Foster, Rhode Island This week, in Foster, Rhode Island, a beef between some teens, and a local police officer kicks off a wild story that leads to multiple murders, prison, lawsuits, calls of small town corruption, and a huge outcry from horrified townspeople. ...
06.09.2023 #394 - The Sudden Passion Of Boobs - Nassau Bay, Texas This week, in Nassau Bay, Texas, did a lesbian affair between two housewives set off a series of events that culminated in a completely different woman, killing her husband, in a public place, in front of many witnesses, and even ...

Older episodes