She cried on national television. She begged for her children's safe return. And for nine days, America believed her.

In October 1994, Susan Smith told police a Black man had carjacked her Mazda with her two sons inside. Three-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander were gone, she sobbed. The nation searched. The nation prayed. But the truth was far darker than any carjacking [citation:1]. 

Smith had rolled her car into John D. Long Lake with her boys strapped into their car seats. A police re-creation showed the car floated for six agonizing minutes before sinking — more than enough time to save them [citation:1]. Her motive? A wealthy lover named Tom Findlay had ended their affair because he did not want children. Prosecutors argued Smith saw her sons as obstacles to a new life [citation:4].

The jury convicted her in just two and a half hours. They spared her the death penalty so she would spend decades reflecting on her crimes. But former prosecutor Tommy Pope says, "Susan has always focused on Susan" [citation:6]. In November 2024, after 30 years behind bars, Smith was denied parole. Her ex-husband David told the board: "Thirty years is just not enough. That's only 15 years per child" [citation:3].

Turn down the lights, put on your headphones, and press play — because some masks never come off.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/red-tree-crime--6847553/support.