On Christmas Eve 1945 a house in Fayetteville, West Virginia burned and five Sodder children were declared lost. Officially ruled an electrical fire, the case is haunted by unexplained details: no human remains, a cleanly cut phone line, a missing ladder, disabled trucks, and later sightings of the children alive.

The family refused to accept the official conclusion and kept searching for answers. This episode examines the strange evidence, eyewitness reports, and the decades-long mystery of what really happened that night.