Michael Barryte and Katie Reed are joined by comedy writer Ryan Finnerty (Ghostmates, Smosh) to figure out whether Grover and Super Grover would be in the same house, if Oscar the Grouch is a Hufflepuff and if Elmo is basically Voldemort.

Follow us on Twitter! Katie Reed @thatkatiereed Michael Barryte @belatedmedia Ryan Finnerty @rpfinnerty

Write to us with theme suggestions and feedback at: [email protected]