Welcome back aboard SS True Crime! 1982 in a small town in Ohio a beloved postal worker was kidnapped and later found murdered. With barely any information to go on the case was going cold until an unlikely source admits to the cold-blooded murder. John Spirko was serving time for another arrest when he told police he had intimate knowledge of what happened to Betty Jo Mottinger. The information John gave the police lead to his eventual conviction and placement on death row, but John claimed it all was a lie after all.