Two years before joining Fleetwood Mac, Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham had no idea what lay ahead of them. They were just two kids who wanted to make great music — and they just happened to be in love.

A cult favorite of Fleetwood Mac fans, this album is — curiously — still only available on vinyl. While bootlegs of the album can be streamed on YouTube, it has never been released on cassette, CD, or to streaming services like Spotify. This is perhaps part of the attraction to the album — this is music that doesn’t outright present itself; it must be found.

In this episode, we discuss why we both call this album their favorite of all time, what makes it unique, and why it still takes our breath away hundreds of listens later.