On November 17, 1978, four young employees at a Burger Chef restaurant in Speedway, Indiana, vanished just after closing. What started as a possible robbery escalated into a horrific kidnapping and mass murder in a wooded area 20 miles away. The victims — two teenage boys and two young women — were killed in different brutal ways, their bodies left in uniforms with some personal items untouched. Despite a massive investigation, false confessions, and multiple suspects, the case remains unsolved. This episode explores the botched crime scene, flawed early police work, leading theories, and why justice has eluded the families for decades.