
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Y’all… buckle up. This week we’re diving into 1923, Season 2, Episode 5 – Only Gunshots to Guide Us – and let me tell you, this one’s a doozy. We’re talking about a seriously heavy, emotionally intense, and, at times, unwatchable episode. And I’m not alone in thinking that – the Facebook groups are on fire with fans who are just as baffled as we are about the direction this show is taking. We’re still all-in on 1923, but man, this episode had us asking: what the heck is Taylor Sheridan doing?
From Alexandra’s devastating arc to Whitfield’s ever-creepier schemes, this episode had us ranting, venting, and questioning everything – including our tolerance for how dark this show is willing to go. We also hit Montana, Wyoming, and even catch up with Spencer and a badass female marshal (more of her, please!). And of course, there’s still no happiness in sight. But hey, at least we got a voiceover from Isabel May, and we’ll take what we can get!
🔥 Episode Timeline Highlights
[1:03] – Why fans (and us) are not loving where this story’s headed
[6:45] – Alexandra’s brutal journey: from the boat to the train, to just about every nightmare in between
[14:21] – The rise of Banner: is the former villain starting to look like an anti-hero?
[22:10] – Spencer’s wild encounter with a salty female marshal (who might be the best character this season)
[31:33] – One powerful line: “Is this the world I killed for?”
[39:15] – Pete’s heartbreaking run-in with Marshal Douchebag
[45:00] – Tiana’s quick cameo and a teaser of what’s to come
[53:25] – We break down the title and wonder: are gunshots really all we have to guide us now?
🔗 Links & Resources
If you made it through this episode – of the show and of our podcast – give yourself a gold star (or at least a shot of whiskey). Don’t forget to follow, rate, and review the podcast if you're loving the recaps – and share it with a fellow 1923 diehard who needs a place to vent. We'll be back next week with Episode 6: The Mountain Teeth of Monsters – and we have no idea what to expect.
See you then… hopefully not at the train station.
—Alex & Jerry 🎙️
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
3.2
2424 ratings
Y’all… buckle up. This week we’re diving into 1923, Season 2, Episode 5 – Only Gunshots to Guide Us – and let me tell you, this one’s a doozy. We’re talking about a seriously heavy, emotionally intense, and, at times, unwatchable episode. And I’m not alone in thinking that – the Facebook groups are on fire with fans who are just as baffled as we are about the direction this show is taking. We’re still all-in on 1923, but man, this episode had us asking: what the heck is Taylor Sheridan doing?
From Alexandra’s devastating arc to Whitfield’s ever-creepier schemes, this episode had us ranting, venting, and questioning everything – including our tolerance for how dark this show is willing to go. We also hit Montana, Wyoming, and even catch up with Spencer and a badass female marshal (more of her, please!). And of course, there’s still no happiness in sight. But hey, at least we got a voiceover from Isabel May, and we’ll take what we can get!
🔥 Episode Timeline Highlights
[1:03] – Why fans (and us) are not loving where this story’s headed
[6:45] – Alexandra’s brutal journey: from the boat to the train, to just about every nightmare in between
[14:21] – The rise of Banner: is the former villain starting to look like an anti-hero?
[22:10] – Spencer’s wild encounter with a salty female marshal (who might be the best character this season)
[31:33] – One powerful line: “Is this the world I killed for?”
[39:15] – Pete’s heartbreaking run-in with Marshal Douchebag
[45:00] – Tiana’s quick cameo and a teaser of what’s to come
[53:25] – We break down the title and wonder: are gunshots really all we have to guide us now?
🔗 Links & Resources
If you made it through this episode – of the show and of our podcast – give yourself a gold star (or at least a shot of whiskey). Don’t forget to follow, rate, and review the podcast if you're loving the recaps – and share it with a fellow 1923 diehard who needs a place to vent. We'll be back next week with Episode 6: The Mountain Teeth of Monsters – and we have no idea what to expect.
See you then… hopefully not at the train station.
—Alex & Jerry 🎙️
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
59 Listeners
9,140 Listeners
86,615 Listeners
13,695 Listeners
691 Listeners
47,696 Listeners
152 Listeners
57,990 Listeners
38,589 Listeners
261 Listeners
1,778 Listeners
579 Listeners
220 Listeners
111 Listeners
42 Listeners
32 Listeners
19 Listeners
86 Listeners
996 Listeners
44 Listeners
3,504 Listeners
53 Listeners
93 Listeners
92 Listeners
28 Listeners
48 Listeners
11 Listeners
131 Listeners
23 Listeners
20 Listeners
15 Listeners
8 Listeners
7,243 Listeners