It's Season 12, Episode 4, American Nightmare, and we are not running scared to talk about how uncomfortable this episode made us. We discuss the running SPN theme of "What is a Monster?" and "Didn't we already decide what a monster was back in season 2?" Also, what DID happen to Sam's psychic abilities? Liz explains what stigmata is, and then tells Diana about one of the most famous stigmatized Saints, Padre Pio of Italy.

Research Links

• Stigmatize - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
• Padre Pio - Wikipedia
• Padre Pio: 13 facts about St. Pio of Pietrelcina to know and share | Catholic News Agency
• Padre Pio | Feast Day, Patron Saint Of, Miracles, Shrine, & Facts | Britannica
• Mystics of the Church: Teresa Musco -Stigmatic, mystic & victim soul
• 10 Infamous Cases Of Stigmata - Listverse