Oct 24, 1953 was the night of the Lacrosse State College Homecoming game in Wisconsin. Evelyn Hartley was 15 and took on a babysitting job. This would be the last night Evelyn was seen. Sources: thecharleyproject.org, storiesoftheunsolved.com, and Wikipedia.org. Email- [email protected], Instagram- @kelliscoffeecrimechat, Facebook- Kelli’s coffee & crime chat, X - @kelliscccpod, Java Momma - Javamomma.com/Kellisjava