On Labor Day 1974, two teenage sisters disappeared from St. Cloud, Minnesota. Despite their parents' pleas, police treated the girls as runaways. Almost a month after their disappearance, the sisters were found....but it was too little, too late. St. Cloud had a dangerous individual living among them, but who was it?

Join Kaylee and Hannah as we discuss the disappearance of Mary Reker and Susanne Reker, and who the main suspects are almost fifty years later.

Anyone with information about this case is requested to contact: Stearns County Sheriff’s office at 320-251-4240.

Like our content? Be sure to follow us on social media!

Instagram @crime_soup

Twitter @crime_coup

TikTok @crimesouppodcast

We also have an awesome new website where you can listen to all past episodes and purchase your very own Crime Soup merch!