The Queens take a bite out of nostalgia and end up with a mouthful of disappointment. In this episode, Trey presents a scathing 1 Star Yelp Review of NYC’s iconic Magnolia Bakery—specifically the once-revered banana pudding. Is it still worthy of the Sex and the City fame, or has it lost all its flavor?

Before the pudding meltdown, Chelsey logs a customer service complaint we all can relate to—being trapped in the purgatory of endless department transfers. Then it’s time for the Review Breakdown, where Chef Earth E. spills the (spoiled?) tea on cupcakes that taste like chemicals, banana pudding made of “whipped air,” and the death of culinary pride.

⏰ Timestamps:

• (00:01:00) Lodge A Complaint – Endless Customer Service Loops
• (00:06:48) Review Breakdown – 1 Star Yelp Review of Magnolia Bakery
• (00:16:09) The Verdict
• (00:18:00) Magnolia’s Reply Breakdown
• (00:18:46) My Royal Highness – Perfect Parking Moment
• (00:22:14) On This Week’s After Show Pod – Penguin Overhead Mask Review

Enjoyed the episode? Don’t forget to rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. Your support helps us grow! 🌟

Prefer to WATCH Your Podcasts? We’ve Got You Covered!

If you love seeing reactions, body language, or just enjoy the visual experience of a podcast, we’ve got full video episodes available on YouTube and Spotify! 📺👀 Watching a podcast can sometimes bring out even more humor, insight, and connection. You can see our unfiltered reactions, laugh along with us, and feel like you're right there in the room. Plus, if you're someone who prefers consuming content visually, this is the perfect way to tune in!

• Watch on YouTube here: Review That Review YouTube Channel
• Don’t forget to Subscribe to get notified about new video episodes: Subscribe to YouTube

Support the Show:

• Review The Pod: LoveThePodcast.com/TheReviewQueens
• Donate: ReviewThatReview.com/Donate
• Join Our Patreon: Unlock bonus content, members-only podcast, and more at Patreon.com/reviewthatreview 🎉

Promo Codes:

• REVIEWQUEEN at clean.email
• REVIEW40 at vitable.com.au
• REVIEWQUEEN at shesbirdie.com
• REVIEWQUEEN40 at NatalieWeissVoice.com
• QUEEN15 at SmartPatches.com
• QUEEN at superchewer.com

Stay Connected:

• Join the Queendom! Sign up for our mailing list for exclusive updates and content.
• Leave us a voicemail: 1-850-REVIEW-0 📞

Follow Us:

• Instagram: @TheReviewQueens | @ChelseyBD | @TreyGerrald

About the Show:

Review That Review is an independent podcast produced by Trey Gerrald and Chelsey Donn. Sound design and editing by Trey Gerrald. Cover art by LogoVora. Theme song by Joe Kinosian, sung by Natalie Weiss. Voiceover by Eva Kaminsky.