Isaac and Chris stare down the Joker (2019). Is this Oscar-winner a top-notch comic book adaptation? Or does it paint Gotham’s famed villains, violence, and decay in too broad of strokes?

Tune in as your hosts work their way through the film’s controversy, acknowledge Todd Phillips’ cross-genre accomplishments, and discuss Joaquin Phoenix’s contribution to the pantheon of actors who have portrayed the Clown Prince of Crime.

Love it? Hate it? Share your own take on Twitter (@pickyourtake), Facebook, YouTube, or by email at [email protected].