Caitlin's pumped for playoff hockey and basketball, meanwhile Gabriel couldn't care less about the Knicks and used to rock an Iverson jersey, so no fireworks there. They recap both teams' weeks before Caitlin makes a call for Philly fan unity and Gabriel sounds off on the Mets' gimmicky home run celebration. The pair also tackle one of baseball's great moral dilemmas: if you snag a ball at the park, do you keep it? The Rivalry Corner heads to 1968—the Year of the Pitcher—Dan Uggla lands on the Chopping Block, and the two close it out with a Mother's Day send-off.

• 00:00 Intro + Look Around the League
• 15:22 Phillies Week in Review
• 20:53 Mets Week in Review
• 30:57 Phitin' Words: Philly Fans Unite!
• 38:13 Amazin' Take: Enough with the gimmicks
• 42:58 Fan Etiquette: Are You Keeping the Ball?
• 56:03 Rivalry Corner: 1968
• 01:02:43 Chopping Block: Dan Uggla's Legacy
• 01:05:41 Picks and Predictions for Upcoming Games
• 01:11:09 Mother's Day Wishes & Baseball Memories