Caitlin & Gabriel look back at the week that was as both teams try to dig out of their early season slumps. The Phillies are surging while the Mets continue their maddening one-step-up, two-steps-back routine. Could A.J. Ewing be the spark the Mets are looking for? Gabriel has a softball epiphany, while Caitlin urges fans to give Crawford time to develop. The main segment asks when it's okay to shut the game off, and the two relive the improbable comebacks they missed by leaving early. The Rivalry Corner revisits the 1969 Miracle Mets, and Death itself lands on The Chopping Block.

• 00:00 Intro & Catching Up
• 03:08 Look Around the League
• 11:17 Phillies Week in Review
• 21:33 Mets Week in Review
• 30:24 Amazin' Take: A Rec Softball Epiphany
• 38:33 Phitin' Words: Give Crawford Some Time
• 41:46 Main Segment: Tuning Out & Leaving Early
• 53:24 The Rivalry Corner: 1969
• 01:02:32 The Chopping Block
• 01:07:09 Looking Ahead: Predictions and Key Players