Like a Churchy Pat Benatar, Amy Grant welcomes us into a world of hard synths and even harder theology in her 1983 hit A Christmas Album. The boys keep the holiday music season rolling along with a deep discussion of this Extremely Mom Album, as well as professorial oversharing, dating someone with the same name as you, and their new status as Icelandic celebrities. And remember: if you’re listening—you’re awesome, dude!