After a grimy lawyer/sex tape enthusiast films Mac in the midst of a beheading, Duncan must outmaneuver the sleazy litigator's efforts to blackmail him into killing his wife while staying one step ahead of the flamboyant Lyman Kurlow, an immortal criminal that escaped Mac's sweet justice centuries ago. The Rewatchers get lost in an epic hedge maze, enjoy some over-the-top theatrics (and an epic pool flip!) from friend of the show Anthony De Longis, and try to "hold it in" for a stakeout with Joe.