When Mac's alleged friend Benny "Kielbasa" Carbassa cooks up a dubious plan to blackmail an aging philanthropist with his gangster past, Kielbasa places Duncan and Anne squarely in the ancient gangster's crosshairs. The Rewatchers try to unpack the inscrutable scheme that places our heroes in danger, debate Kielbasa's cartoonish performance, and get bummed out by Anne's puzzling and self-destructive decision to get back together with Duncan.