​How does a teenager vanish on a familiar street in broad daylight? The abduction of Mary Lou Arruda transformed Raynham from a peaceful suburb into a landscape of fear. A two-month search eventually led deep into the woods, but the discovery of her body was only the beginning of a larger nightmare. This week, we dive into a haunting case involving a local doughnut maker, controversial investigative techniques, and a legal battle that spanned four separate trials over two decades. Lock your doors as we uncover a story where the evidence is clear, but the path to justice is crooked.