In this episode of Demystifying Mental Toughness, David Charlton continues in part two of his solo series exploring the 4Cs of Mental Toughness through the coach–athlete relationship lens.

The focus this week is Emotional Control and a common but misunderstood dynamic in sport: the emotionally reactive coach and the calm, composed athlete.

While passion and intensity are often seen as leadership qualities, strong emotional reactions, sarcasm or outcome-focused language can unintentionally create a fear-based environment. When athletes feel judged or humiliated, the brain's threat system activates, reducing attention, decision-making and learning.

At the same time, athletes who regulate their emotions well are often misunderstood. Calm behaviour can be interpreted as a lack of care or motivation, leading to unnecessary conflict.

Drawing on research around the coach–athlete relationship and youth brain development, this episode explains how emotional climate shapes confidence, creativity and long-term engagement in sport.

Listeners will also learn a simple framework for understanding emotional intensity and regulation, along with practical strategies for improving communication and psychological safety.

>> Key Takeaways

• Fear and public criticism trigger threat responses that reduce learning and decision-making
• Calm athletes often care deeply, emotional control is a coping style, not disengagement
• Performance improves when coaches combine passion with emotional regulation and relational awareness

If you enjoyed this episode, check out part one of my mini-series and our previous podcasts on all things mental toughness:

Ep304 – David Charlton - Life Control: When Coaches and Athletes Think Differently

Ep303: Doug Strycharczyk - Why You Think the Way You Do Under Pressure

Ep302: Doug Strycharczyk - Why You React the Way You Do Under Pressure

Ep293: Stuart Barnes - High Challenge, High Support: Mental Toughness in Cricket

Ep249: Edward Hall - Workplace Collaboration in Team Sports Coaching Environments

Connect with David Charlton

· Sign Up To The Mental Edge

· Join David @ The Sports Psychology Hub

· LinkedIn