The cast, including new regular Katie Hill, discusses the best “I told you so” moments they have, or have not, shared in their lives, all while Jett tries his hardest to keep the show on the rails. We get self-gaslighting relationships with strange car analogies that turn into stranger scenes with worse relationship analogies, we get attempts to look like good people, we visit a well-picked hill to die on, we look back fondly on the political scandals of olde, and Josh gets some important advice from his dad crossed over from the other side!

Cast: Chris Compton, Katie Hill, Jarrett Lennon Kaufman, Josh Spence 

Ads: Que Blato (improvised by Chris Sanders) 

Original release date: 4/30/25 

Intro and outro music credit to Matt Walker 

Music: Silken Notes by Sascha Ende 

Music: Salsa Serenade by Justin Allan Arnold 

Music: Myocardial Infarction by Tim Kulig