A close reading of 2 Timothy 2:24–25 and its role inside Socinian pastoral practice. We trace how Faustus Socinus and the Polish Brethren turned Paul's counsel—"the Lord's servant must not be quarrelsome but kind"—into a systematic method of calm, rational disputation and a principled stand against coercion. This episode situates that method in its seventeenth‑century controversies and shows why a single Pauline paragraph became a touchstone for theology, pedagogy, and religious freedom.