Alex and Ashley go head to head on a controversial pick: 2004's Win a Date with Tad Hamilton! starring Topher Grace, Kate Bosworth, and Josh Duhamel. Did Pete mess up Rosalee's life by confessing his love for her? Should she have chosen Tad and live a lie? Why does Gennifer Goodwin's hair have that weird color streak in it? All valid questions that we're too drunk to remember if we covered.

GP Wreck-o-mends: In-N-Out and Monster Energy Drinks

Twitter/IG: @garbagepunch

EMAIL US: [email protected]

Subscribe and we love you!