Confusing Duncan for his murderous Roma friend Gelato (yum!), the Watchers start an all-out manhunt for Mac and Joe. Our heroes try to diffuse the situation with an entertaining mix of betrayal, yelling, and self-deception, which threatens to tear the MacLeod gang apart. The Rewatchers try to figure out the sudden brotherhood between immortals in this episode, mull over the appropriate punishment for Gelato (spoiler, he melts), and clean up their Miller Lite breath with “Methos: the fresh maker.”