At the Leagues Cup break we did a midseason episode breaking down how we thought each player did up to that point. But now that the 2025 Columbus Crew season is officially in the books it’s time for the end of the year grade cards! In this episode, we break down every Crew player’s performance from the 2025 MLS season, delivering each player their A+ to F report cards with full analysis on consistency, impact, injuries, and overall contribution. Who stepped up in the biggest moments? Who disappointed? And who still looks like a key piece for 2026 and beyond? This is your Columbus Crew individual player recap, player evaluation, and roster outlook heading into 2026.

Major changes are coming to MLS. In this episode, we break down MLS’s plan to shift the league calendar starting in summer 2027 and we weigh the pros and cons. We also dive into the growing rumors linking Wilfried Nancy to Celtic FC and how a move would shape the club’s future. Plus: Italy’s shocking implosion to Norway, the latest from the USMNT camp, and a rundown of Columbus Crew 2’s recent contract decisions. Even with our season done for 2025, the news doesn't stop rolling in!

The 2025 Columbus Crew season ended in the toughest way possible… a Game 3 playoff loss to FC Cincinnati in Hell Is Real. We break down the Crew’s 2025 MLS Cup Playoffs elimination after falling in the First Round, react to what went wrong in the 2-1 loss, and talk through the emotions of a rivalry postseason heartbreak. But then with the season officially over, we turn to the future. What does Columbus need to fix in 2026? Which players showed out, who took a step back, and what moves does the front office need to make this offseason? We give a full Columbus Crew roster breakdown, talk offseason needs, transfer priorities, contract questions, and what it will take to get back to MLS Cup contention.

#ColumbusCrew #Crew96 #MLS #MLSPlayoffs #HellIsReal #SoccerPodcast #MajorLeagueSoccer #MLSCup

HELL IS STILL REAL! And the Columbus Crew just made it very real for FC Cincinnati. After dropping Game 1 on the road, the Crew stormed back with a statement 4-0 win in Game 2 to even the MLS Cup Playoff series and force a decisive Game 3. It was pure domination from start to finish: relentless pressing, killer finishing, and that signature Wilfried Nancy swagger. In this episode, we break down how Columbus flipped the rivalry on its head, who stepped up when it mattered most, and what needs to happen to take down FCC once and for all in Game 3. We also talk through the rest of the MLS Cup Playoffs, which teams are looking scary, and what this Crew performance says about their title chances.

Game 1 of the MLS Cup Playoffs didn’t go the Crew’s way, but this Hell Is Real rivalry series is far from over. We recap Columbus Crew’s 1–0 loss to FC Cincinnati, including lineup decisions, tactical breakdowns, and key moments that shaped the match at TQL Stadium. From scoring struggles and defensive adjustments to how players like Arfsten and Herrera underperformed in key moments, we cover what must change for Columbus to bounce back in Game 2 at Lower.com Field. If you’re a Columbus Crew fan or following the MLS Cup Playoffs, this recap has you covered.

The Columbus Crew and FC Cincinnati meet in the Audi MLS Cup Playoffs for the 2nd ever time. But instead of the Eastern Finals, this time we start with them with a first round tie..and it’s everything we’ve been waiting for! In this episode, the guys break down the massive Hell Is Real showdown: key matchups, where we think we can exploit our neighbors from Kentucky, predictions, and what it’ll take for the Crew to advance. Plus, we give our full predictions for every other first-round playoff series across MLS.

Who’s going home early? Who’s making a Cup run?

#Crew96 #ColumbusCrew #FCCincinnati #HellIsReal #MLSPlayoffs

It was a night of celebration and goodbyes in Columbus. The Crew finished the season with a statement 3-1 win, skipping the Wild Card game and honoring Darlington Nagbe in his final regular season home appearance.Herrera, Gazdag, and Aliyu found the back of the net as Columbus closed strong heading into the playoffs. In this episode, we react to the win, reflect on Nagbe’s impact, and make our first-round MLS playoff predictions.

It’s a massive week for American soccer and Columbus Crew fans alike. We kick things off with the U.S. U20 World Cup run, breaking down their impressive journey and tough quarterfinal loss. From there, we dive into the latest USMNT camp and matches, analyzing key performances and roster trends heading into the next international window. In MLS it’s Decision Day this Saturday as the Columbus Crew close out the regular season. We discuss playoff positioning and the legacy of Darlington Nagbe following his official retirement announcement. And to wrap up, we react to MLS experimenting with AI-generated match recaps and what it means for storytelling, coverage, and the human side of the sport. Spoiler: We aren't fans.

In this episode of 4 The Crew, we connect the dots between club and country as Columbus Crew players earn U.S. national team call-ups at every level — U17, U19, U20, and the full USMNT roster. It’s proof of just how strong the MLS development system has become in Columbus. Then, we dive into a full USMNT roster analysis, breaking down key inclusions, surprise omissions, and what it all means for Mauricio Pochettino and the road to the 2026 World Cup. If you’re a Crew fan, a US soccer supporter, or just love deep, thoughtful soccer talk, this is the episode for you.

It was a night of both encouraging returns and frustrating moments as the Crew drew 1-1 with Orlando City. Herrera’s goal from a sharp Lappalainen assist gave fans something to cheer about, while Schulte giving up a soft goal summed up the team’s defensive woes. One huge positive though was that Rossi and Zawadzki made their returns and helped solidify the team. We also talk about young talents like Picard and Habroune going into next season and what we want to see from them. In summary we recap the match, look ahead to what the Crew roster might need this offseason (and we needs to go), and highlight the positives in an up-and-down performance.