Chris and Isaac take the plunge with Lady in the Water (2006). Is Story’s story an instant bedtime classic? Or does the movie simply not hold water?

Cross over with your hosts into the (sometimes unreliable) imagination of M. Night Shyamalan, discuss when they find camerawork effective versus distracting, and commend Bryce Dallas Howard’s inevitable ascent to directorhood.

Love it? Hate it? Share your take on Twitter (@pickyourtake), Facebook, YouTube, or by email at [email protected].