Is Dawson and Gretchen's relationship hopeless? There seems to be some doubts this episode as their age difference becomes a bit more noticeable than they'd both like. Also... what's the trouble with "nice guys"? Traci and Charles discuss why nice guys probably *don't* finish last. Plus, Joey and Pacey are off on a terrible double date, and Mr. Brooks has been hoarding his medication – which leads to a dire situation.