In 1981, Ken McElroy was shot dead in broad daylight… in front of nearly 60 people.

And somehow, no one saw a thing.

This week, Josh, Audrey, and Seth head to Skidmore, Missouri, to unravel the chilling story of a town terrorized, a justice system that failed, and the moment when fear turned into silence. Known as the “town bully,” McElroy escaped conviction again and again. Until one summer morning when the entire town gathered, shots rang out, and an unspoken pact was born.

Was it vigilante justice? A collective breaking point? Or the perfect crime hidden in plain sight?

We break down McElroy’s long trail of violence, the investigation that went nowhere, and the haunting question that still lingers over Skidmore:

What happens when everyone knows… and no one talks?