This week we discuss stories from the state of Ohio, Niko takes us back to early Truth And Scare vibes with the unsettling story of the Poison Pen, AKA the Circleville Letter Writer. Then Cyndi takes us on a haunted tour of Franklin Castle, where apparently there are just straight-up bones in the walls. Remember to leave a rate and review on apple podcasts and share us with a friend! And, as always, stay spooky! Okay, byeee!!!


Join the community discord (18+) to be a part of episode discussions, suggest new topics, and see lots of animal pictures: https://discord.gg/NdWB5NUgwS


Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our bonus episodes!     

Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!       

Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram