The teams are in! The dice are fuzzy! The capers… are deeply concerning!

Welcome back to The Muppet Caper Draft, where the only thing wilder than the picks are the plots! In Part 2, the hosts reveal their full heist-ready lineups—8 Muppet heroes, 3 villainous puppets, and 2 confused human celebrities per team—and pitch the chaotic Muppet movies they were born to direct!

Whose crew includes Rowlf as a getaway pianist? Who drafted Elmo and Oscar just to watch the world burn? And who’s sending the Fraggles into deep space with Jason Segel? These are the questions that demand answers!

In this installment, we put our picks to the test with full caper synopses, heated debates over tone (Gritty noir or pure vaudeville?), and multiple lawsuits from The Swedish Chef! No puppet is safe! No draft pick goes unjudged! And no, we still don’t know what Telly’s deal is!

🎭 Featuring:

• 3 completely unhinged Muppet movies
• 1 surprisingly emotional moment with Big Bird
• 0 respect for the Henson estate
• 100% commitment to the bit

Listen! Draft! Regret nothing!