What happened on the night of February 16, 1970 in Fort Bragg, North Carolina at the MacDonald house? Jeffrey MacDonald claims four people broke in and murdered his pregnant wife and two children, but was convicted of the murders in 1979. This week, Kait (@bubblinequeen) and her guest Steph (@stephdraz) walk you through both scenarios, go through reasons why he could be innocent or guilty and try to figure out what really happened that night in 1970.

Sources: My Favorite Murder Podcast.