Jeep sales are setting new records, driven by models like the new Renegade. These models might help Fiat-Chrysler Group's balance sheet, but do they risk alienating traditionalists? To find out, we invited George to bring in his off-road-ready 1999 Jeep Cherokee. Other than mercilessly mocking his project Jeep's various shortcomings, we talk about how the Renegade fits with the brand, how it matches customer expectations, and if it's a good value or not. Next we answer some reader complaints about reliability and recommendations, particularly comparing the Jeep Cherokee and Volkswagen Golf. Finally, we look at the VW Golf R, the top-trim model of the legendary GTI hot hatch. As expected, the gang is split on the car's appeal and value.