This week, Luke and Jordan begin with the Chupacabra—a creature that struck fear across the U.S. and Mexico in the 1990s, and then vanished without explanation.

But the real story emerges after the first break, when Jordan recounts a trip to a flea market in Oaxaca, where he discovered a series of strange Polaroids… and a name the locals no longer speak out loud: José Luis de la Rosa.