This mystery revolves around a family in Horicon, Wisconsin, in the 1980s and it all started when a family bought a second-hand bunk bed for their two daughters. Later on, they figured out that it was a big mistake when they had to face demonic forces, terrified priests, floating paintbrushes, random sicknesses, and a red eyed woman in black. Delve down deep into the story that also aired on the show Unsolved Mysteries and is deemed one of the most iconic and scariest episodes to date. Tune in to find out why.