Kurt Money and Kateline discuss the 2012 Staten Island murder of Simeonette Mapes-Crupi. Was it her husband, Jonathan's sneaker collection that inspired a burglary gone wrong? Or was it the silencing of a witness who saw a gang member murdered across the street? We're not spoiling but we can tell you the murderer went to the only hardware store ever mentioned on Dateline, Home Depot! This episode is not sponsored by Home Depot but it is sponsored by Shakespeare's MacBeth.

The Dateline episode discussed is "The Secrets of the Sliding Door" that originally aired on NBC on May 4th, 2025, hosted by Keith Morrison.

Check out the video version of this podcast posting on the YouTube page tomorrow! And search "Aisle H" on Patreon to get two bonus episodes a month about Dateline-adjacent content!