Meet Michael and Nick for the twelfth time as they catch the shining glimmer of A Knife in the Dark.

Michael wonders whether the end of the chapter was an appropriate cliff hanger, adores the tale of Tinuviel, and is beyond confused over the whereabouts of Aragorn as Frodo is stabbed by the ringwraith.

Nick expresses his dislike for the scene change away from Frodo's perspective, further analyses the ringwraiths teamwork and abilities, and ponders the possibility of Frodo being killed off this early in the book.