What if Elizabeth and Darcy had met before Netherfield—only for things to go terribly wrong?

This week, we’re talking about A Shared History by Abigail Sheffield, a dual-timeline Pride and Prejudice variation that asks: can you rebuild something beautiful after a painful ending?

With strong Persuasion energy and a narrative that moves between past and present, this story explores what happens when deep hurt meets enduring love. We dive into all the messy, relatable parts of learning to trust again, what it takes to offer a second chance, and how to know when someone’s really changed.

We also take a few side quests along the way—into Little Women adaptations, pre-pandemic moviegoing, and quick stops at Grey’s Anatomy, Harry Potter, and Barbie. 

This variation gave us all the emotional complexity we love in a second-chance romance—and reminded us just how satisfying it is when Elizabeth and Darcy finally find their way back to each other.

P.S. Be honest—how did you feel about Emma Watson as Meg? Let us know in the comments!

🎵 Music Credit:

Pride & Prejudice Book Club Theme composed, performed, and arranged by Megan Mason.

📚 Curious what we will be reading next? See a list of upcoming books at prideandprejudicebookclub.com!

➡️ Follow us on Facebook and Instagram, or sign up for our newsletter at https://www.prideandprejudicebookclub.com/newsletter!