Strange Finds recounts unusual and unsettling encounters. In this particular episode, the story details finding an unlabeled cassette tape at a thrift store and the eerie events that followed playing it. The recording contained a creepy voice warning against rewinding, a warning the host initially ignored. Rewinding the tape led to more disturbing phenomena, including disembodied whispers and a menacing phone call. The story concludes with the mysterious disappearance of the tape and an ominous note suggesting the host has broken a cycle, implying the tape may resurface for someone else.