What (15:15) did Alex mean when she said she lost “everything”? (7:45) Why does Donald Whitfield’s house look familiar? (29:15) When will Spencer get to Montana? This week, Billy Dukes and Adison Haager offer a mid-season grade and try to answer all the burning 1923 questions. Episode 4 moved every character’s plot line forward but it was hardly good news for everyone.

This week’s (35:45) expanded Q&A includes fan questions and theories about Alexandra, Elsa, Jacob and Cara and more. Y’all were very good this week, with concepts that left us shellshocked. Email [email protected] and check out TasteofCountryStore.com for Y Collection t-shirts and more. The winner of (2:15) this week’s trivia gets to pick out a shirt to keep.